I agree with you on the complacency being dangerous and I think complacency could kill you in any demanding sport (skiiing for one), but don't want to continue with too many ski parallels.DameDykker once bubbled...
So then the question is: When are you good enough???
I'll never be a good skier. I just barely manage a black every once in a while and I only ever skied one week a year (now even less - time for diving, you know ). Hoever, I really enjoy skiing. Would I like to be better- yes, but realisticly seen it's not going to happen.
The difference with diving is that that complacency - which is allright in many situations - could kill you when you'r diving! So maybe the quesion is wether the agenies will actually tell the students that this could be dangerous. And this could kill you. And a BOW course is just a learners permit. However, then it should also be possible to tell the students what they should master to be "good enough". And that is of course difficult.
On the other hand many divers with around 100 dives fell they are doing reaaly good and have a lot of eksperience but they mey just have done the one dive 100 times (as mentioned previously in this tread). Also doing mask clearing yesterday in the pool, my dive body and I both admitted that we havn't done a mask clearing in ages - as we have well fitting masks. There wasn't any problems with mask clearing. However, you mignt do a lot of dives but not be sufficienly aware that your last night dive was two years ago. Or your last dive to more that 20m was last summer.
So complacency is a dangerous thing.
You bring up a good point that I had not thought about..when is enough reached? I have no idea and hope others will continue the discussion, but I know I can't stand the people who know very little yet are happy about it and sometimes even argumentative. You know the types - "I don't need to know all that stuff...why would you need that to dive?" "That's a waste of time, I just follow the DM or my computer" "All this learning and skills are making diving not fun"