And here I was thinking that GC was one of the higher end Caribbean dive islands.
To be fair, let's consider the competition (other Caribbean islands).
1.) Grand Cayman joins Providenciales in a reputation for being expensive Caribbean dive destinations (though airfare and car rentals on G.C. trips may be well-priced, at least when I looked in the past).
2.) 7 Mile Beach is a nice offering, and they've got 'brand name' resorts like the Westin, etc... That can be a comfort to some tourists.
3.) The same cruise industry that swamps Georgetown with tourists also helps provide a market for topside excursions. So there are dolphin encounters, the Turtle Farm, etc... If shopping or eating out are your thing, you can do that.
4.) It's got some shore diving, which puts it on a short list of Caribbean destinations (e.g.: with Bonaire, Curacao, Cayman Brac and St. Croix).
5.) From what
@KathyV has posted before, the mosquito abatement program is good. I haven't been sick on Grand Cayman; it seems to have a rep. as a 'first world' level place, so if I were bringing a 'sickly' (or very young) loved one on a trip, that'd be a big 'pro.' over, oh, say, Bonaire.
6.) A number of Caribbean islands have 'dirt under their rug' in terms of crime. ABC journalist Anne Swaney was murdered in Belize (not an island, I know, but in the region), and reporting indicated odds of murderers getting caught and convicted in Belize were...scary low. Home break-ins in Bonaire have been a concern. I've read scary things about St. Thomas. The Bay Islands seem to have a decent safety rep., unlike
mainland Honduras, whose city San Pedro Sula was referred to as the 'murder capital of the world' a few years back.
I'm not saying Grand Cayman is 'better' than Little Cayman or Cayman Brac, but it probably is for some people. If we're going to knock it, to be fair we need to compare against other destinations with a fairly large (by Caribbean standards) city with lots to do topside. Maybe Cozumel (San Miguel) and Curacao (Willemstad)? I imagine Cayman Brac feels 'safer' (if you don't need a large hospital very close - no offense to
Faith Hospital), but that's a different kind of vacation topside.