Cave diver drowns - Jackson Blue Springs, Florida

[billgraham]

That doesn't sound wildly different from what I was taught in GUE fundies. I was told to present the reg calmly right in front of the OOG diver, easy to see and grab, and to grab their elbow/arm to reassure them and as GI3 said in the DIR tapes "take control of the situation". Obviously no aggressive moves, and there wasn't much emphasis on defending/turning them around, but to stabilize and make sure the OOG diver is ok and calm.

That's solid technique and I think the defensive angle is highlighted by the description of what went on before he got there. Another good takeaway from this is the chaotic scene and inability of the other divers present in the cave to communicate with each other and Edd.

 

[tmassey]

If you know about ocean rescue of a panicked swimmer, it's something similar, you go underwater and turn them around if they try to climb on your head.

Thank you for this, both asking Edd directly and your description.

I loved panic diver on the surface in my rescue class. And the concept you’re conveying really translates: grab their opposite hand, spin them around and grab them from behind. You’re not actually doing that in this case, but you’re prepared to.

My original open water instructor told us that the octo was not for a buddy, the octo was for us when our out of gas buddy grabs ours out of our mouth. I’ve repeated that to a couple of people and got blasted, saying that nobody has ever seen an out of air diver react in a panicked way. It’s interesting to hear anecdotes in this thread to the contrary.

I know that this concept is something that I have now been thinking about and will definitely add elements of to my out of air practice. It doesn’t even really change anything that the out of a gas diver will necessarily even notice, which I guess is kind of the point: do nothing to provoke them while making sure you can still stay in control of the situation. If anything, it’s just as much mental preparation and mindset on the part of the donating diver. Anyway, thanks for your reply.

 

[billgraham]

I loved panic diver on the surface in my rescue class. And the concept you’re conveying really translates: grab their opposite hand, spin them around and grab them from behind. You’re not actually doing that in this case, but you’re prepared to.

I think you don't want to grab their hand because then they grab you. You can ask Edd about it but his point is once you have that upper arm, they have a much harder time getting a hand on you.

 

[Steelyeyes]

I think you don't want to grab their hand because then they grab you. You can ask Edd about it but his point is once you have that upper arm, they have a much harder time getting a hand on you.

I was taught to go negative, swim under or past and come up and control them by grabbing their first stage and lock legs on either side of their tank. They can't take your air source that way. I'd stay well clear of a panicked person's hands.

 

[Endler's]

Read somewhere, that after you have handed off your stage, to show your gas pressure gauge to the OOG diver. Calms them down, by letting them know how much gas, you both have left to work with. Sounds like a good idea to me.

 

[billgraham]

Read somewhere, that after you have handed off your stage, to show your gas pressure gauge to the OOG diver. Calms them down, by letting them know how much gas, you both have left to work with. Sounds like a good idea to me.

In my limited experience with panicked divers, they aren't going to look at anything or be able to communicate with you.

 

[boulderjohn]

In my limited experience with panicked divers, they aren't going to look at anything or be able to communicate with you.

I have no experience with panicked divers whatsoever, but I doubt one would get calmed down by the appearance of an SPG. I think getting to breathe your air for a while is better.

 

[rjack321]

Read somewhere, that after you have handed off your stage, to show your gas pressure gauge to the OOG diver. Calms them down, by letting them know how much gas, you both have left to work with. Sounds like a good idea to me.

YOUR stage has its own SPG. Showing them your gauge is pointless.

We dont hand off stages to stressed divers, that just leads to them OOG again when the stage dies.
OOG divers go on a long hose until they calm down, then they can take a stage to move slightly faster on exit.

 

[stuartv]

YOUR stage has its own SPG. Showing them your gauge is pointless.

We dont hand off stages to stressed divers, that just leads to them OOG again when the stage dies.
OOG divers go on a long hose until they calm down, then they can take a stage to move slightly faster on exit.

I think he meant "handed off your 2nd stage [regulator]...".

 

[KevinNM]

That doesn't sound wildly different from what I was taught in GUE fundies. I was told to present the reg calmly right in front of the OOG diver, easy to see and grab, and to grab their elbow/arm to reassure them and as GI3 said in the DIR tapes "take control of the situation". Obviously no aggressive moves, and there wasn't much emphasis on defending/turning them around, but to stabilize and make sure the OOG diver is ok and calm.

I’ve taken both and Edd puts a lot more focus on how dangerous this can be and on how to not get killed doing this. IIRC he’s had some bad experiences with rescues.