Not too worried about the Expanded Self-Defense Law in Bonaire. I'm pretty sure if my boyfriend had caught him, he wouldn't be doing too much talking.
Not one thing that was taken from us had any resale value.
Not a lot of resale value in the half empty bottle of Gatorade.
Old pair of shorts: $1.00 - maybe.
Sunglasses : They cost $4.99 new.
Little cooler: Was a freebie from a sporting event.
Except for the drink & cooler, I am sure the thief was hoping for some money hidden in a pocket. He or she got nothing of value at all.
But my boyfriend & I both lost our dive logs & both our C cards, plus business cards & phone numbers that we had accumulated during our travels. Plus almost a full day of diving on Bonaire, as we filed a police report & walked up & down the road looking for a sign of our books. We never found a thing.
I would not hesitate to return to Bonaire. I thought the island was beautiful & the diving amazing. But as far as theft not being a big deal...spend a few hours sitting in the police station as a parade of tourists come in to file reports. I think you will have a different opinion.