DiscoVolante
Registered
Ok this is an old thread, but I just read the book and found it to be quite entertaining. The writing might not be nobel prize material, but then again I have read and enjoyed worse books, and at least the topic of this one interests me. This, could of course be due to english not being my first language 
I do not know enough about the truth regarding the "Shadow Divers" to comment on this particular subject. But in general i would say that;
If someone knows that the information claimed to be true by others, is in fact misleading or even false. I would say that it is fine if that someone tried to set the record straight.
Again - I cannot say what is correct in this specific case, but I do get the feeling that many of the people who are critizing his work are doing so without much more knowledge about the truth than I have.

I do not know enough about the truth regarding the "Shadow Divers" to comment on this particular subject. But in general i would say that;
If someone knows that the information claimed to be true by others, is in fact misleading or even false. I would say that it is fine if that someone tried to set the record straight.
Again - I cannot say what is correct in this specific case, but I do get the feeling that many of the people who are critizing his work are doing so without much more knowledge about the truth than I have.