Best military units of all time

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

AQUA PROP:
Cheers big ears. But
Did anybody else have a bad taste left in their mouth after the last shindig we all attended. After 3/4 of the dust has settled it seems it had a lot more to do with oil and power than WOMD. I don't think little iron ( I didn't have any friends at school and this george guy likes me) johnny will get away with that ever again. There are a lot of very unhappy voters over here right now. The last person I'd be putting my butt on the line for is a politician going for office again next election. I dont think you can rate this one till it's over. Hope all that are still over there stay safe and sound.

britanic bold It had to do with fighting militant Islam, establishing a
military force next to Israels enemies and protecting the oil fields. We've fought wars over less...like protecting Australia from the Japanese.
 
The book is all about the Trojans stand at Thermopylae

It was the Spartans at Thermopylae.

One Unit that should be added to this list is Napoleons "Old Guard" I would probably have to add the Canadian Division at Vimy Ridge. After Months of efforts by both the French and British they took the position in one day. When it comes to Naval Units I really think the honors has to go to any of the Allied escorts on the Murmansk run in WW2. Not only did they have to brave Uboats but they did it in severe weather in reach of German Condors. I would second the RAF during the Battle of Britain and add the Tuskegee Airman to the list as deserving of a very special place in US Military history.
 
hoover:
britanic bold It had to do with fighting militant Islam, establishing a
military force next to Israels enemies and protecting the oil fields. We've fought wars over less...like protecting Australia from the Japanese.

Sorry, which history book says that the US joined WWII (after several years of combat in Europe) to defend the Australians from the Japanese? Or are you referring to a different conflict?

And if it's all about fighting militant groups why aren't they invading Africa?
 
hoover:
britanic bold It had to do with fighting militant Islam, establishing a
military force next to Israels enemies and protecting the oil fields. We've fought wars over less...like protecting Australia from the Japanese.

Geez! :fire:

Hoover, did you forget about Pearl Harbor! :realmad: I suggest that study the history of WW II! Yes, we did help protect the Australians, however; they were pretty busy in North Africa and other places. :nonono:
 
hoover:
[ We've fought wars over less...like protecting Australia from the Japanese.
Oh, that's not a bad idea at all ... I certainly prefer Castlemaine XXXX and VB to Kirin ... Then again, the Landcruiser isn't a bad piece of kit, compared to a Holden ... :yippie17:

I'm trying to keep away from this debate, as the flaming potential is huge, and there will be a natural bias on this forum toward a certain Western Hemisphere superpower ... (hint: not Canada. Not outside hockey, anyhow ... :ek2: )

But all things relative, I think many observers of WWII history would argue that the New Zealand forces, unit for unit and considering the size of the country, were the best Allied land forces of that conflict. At sea? Well, the U.S. Navy would probably have to be considered nec plus ultra during WWII for their combined Pacific and Atlantic accomplishments, although the Canadians and Brits did sterling work in the Atlantic (and for the latter, the Mediterranean, too).

Oh my God! I've done it, I'm involved ... time to beat a hasty retreat ...

:redcap:
 
Gen Sam Houston against the Mexican army at San Jacinto

Henry V at Antigone...


I did see someone mention Willam Barrett Travis at the Alamo

TwoBit
 
Slow posting day in the RB section, I'm loitering ... unfortunately my knowledge in military history isn't large enough to join the military end of the discussion.
6Gill:
One foreign hostage rescue unit not mentioned also has had some great operations is Germany's GS G9.
Maybe the GrenzSchutzGruppe9 hasn't been mentioned because it is not a military unit, but rather part of the federal border patrol (Bundesgrenzschutz). As such they are more comparable to the FBI's Hostage Rescue Team then let's say Delta or DEVGRU. Germany has rough equivalents to those units in their military, too. Kommando Spezialkräfte (KSK) and Kampfschwimmer (combat swimmers), but as the German post WWII military goes, they haven't seen all that much combat action. KSK has been heavily involved in Bosnia, successfully hunting and bagging war criminals.

As for "The German Answer To Terrorism", GSG9 is an excellent unit. Their 78 takedown of the hijacked Lufthansa plane 'Landshut' in Mogadishu under the watchfull eyes of two senior SAS officers was a perfect example for a plane takedown.
The Israelis did the same in Entebbe, 77 I believe, as did the GIGN in Paris in 94.
Unfortunately, German politics have changed, and GSG9 hasn't been used, or allowed to do much more than stand by and watch.
Shame on those politicians.
 
fins wake:
Oh my God! I've done it, I'm involved ... time to beat a hasty retreat ...

:redcap:
Too late Fins you’re doomed, you joined in and expressed an opinion!!!! I have to agree the ANZAC forces were superb in North Africa. The US Navy in the Pacific were monsters.....then again, Japan had no chance in competing against the US industrially. The British Gurka's have demostrated time and time again that they are some of the best troops when it comes to shock value. Now I am TOTALY biased here, being a US Marine, the US Marines have proved themselves time and time again since the Seminole Wars in the 1820's to be hard core warriors.

The Roman Legions in the hey day of the Roman Empire were some tough troopers who put up with more then most armies have ever thought to put up with.

That is my 2 cents worth, flame away!

Paul
USMCR 88-03
 
... so I can beat that hasty retreat when needed ... I'll stay on familiar, safe ground.
caveseeker7:
Maybe the GrenzSchutzGruppe9 hasn't been mentioned because it is not a military unit, but rather part of the federal border patrol (Bundesgrenzschutz). As such they are more comparable to the FBI's Hostage Rescue Team then let's say Delta or DEVGRU. As for "The German Answer To Terrorism", GSG9 is an excellent unit.
They are indeed! In fact, with the British SAS Pagoda teams - don't know what the exact terms for the AT units are right now - and the French GIGN, you've probably got the 3 most accomplished hostage rescue/antiterrorist units right there.

There are other superbly trained AT units in the Western world, e.g. SFODF-D (Delta), DEVGRU, HRT, RAID (another French police unit, but not from the Gendarmerie), NOCS, the SBS Black Group etc, but none of these have really had the sort of succesful high-profile operations in civilian hostage rescue situations that GSG9 had at Mogadishu, the SAS had at Princess Gate or GIGN had e.g. in Mekkah. In fact, the GIGN - which is very similar to GSG9, far more so than to SAS - is probably the world's most experienced hostage rescue force, having been used more than most other units combined ...

No disrespect to any members of the Tribe, SEALs or HRT. The former have been proved in combat many times, and all are superbly trained. In fact, the Delta boys and girls are reputedly the best AT assault shooters of them all ... It's just a question of getting a chance to exhibit those skills ...
caveseeker7:
Their 78 takedown of the hijacked Lufthansa plane 'Landshut' in Mogadishu under the watchfull eyes of two senior SAS officers was a perfect example for a plane takedown.
Absolutely. Just a few minor points. The Mogadishu action was in October 1977, and only one SAS operative was an officer (Major Morrison), the other being a NCO (Sergeant Davies of writing fame). Minor niggles, I know, but most NCO:s past and present are a bit particular about not being considered officers ... ahem ...
caveseeker7:
Unfortunately, German politics have changed, and GSG9 hasn't been used, or allowed to do much more than stand by and watch.
The Bundeswehr has always been a bit hostile to Special Forces operations - much like the US Army right up to very recently - and that aspect has been neglected. The idea now is that KSK will take over these duties for actions abroad, but of course, although very well trained they haven't had the chance to exhibit their skills like GSG9 already have ...

That's one of the advantages of having superb AT forces and being willing to use them: the terrorists go for easier targets.
 
wstein:
The US Navy in the Pacific were monsters.....then again, Japan had no chance in competing against the US industrially.
True, but that's assuming the US actually had the means to survive the first, heavy blows struck by the Imperial Japanese Navy. Not only did the USN quickly regroup after the Pearl Harbour disaster and improvise a quick defence, but actually gained a rapid stalemate through superb efforts leading up to and including the Battle of Midway. From then on, Nimitz led a fantastic campaign. Probably the greatest strategist of the war (with the possible exception of the hamstrung Manstein) and it's always the strategists who win wars ...
wstein:
The British Gurka's have demostrated time and time again that they are some of the best troops when it comes to shock value.
The Gurkhas are Nepalese, and have served not only Britain but also India with distinction for over a century and a half, and lately the Sultan of Brunei. (Indian Gurkha units are as highly regarded as their British Army counterparts.) The Gurkha soldier has a strong claim to being perhaps the world's best infantryman. In the Falklands war, it used to be said that Gurkhas could run up a hill faster than a British infantryman could run down ...
wstein:
Now I am TOTALY biased here, being a US Marine, the US Marines have proved themselves time and time again since the Seminole Wars in the 1820's to be hard core warriors.
I realize this is touchy, but historically the US Marines must ranks paramount among the nation's warriors during the last 100 years ... It's interesting that the first major ground force units into Afghanistan were US Marines. Afghanistan is entirely landlocked ... That's saying something.
 

Back
Top Bottom