Are weight belts dangerous?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

There are three buckle designs: thread-thru “force friction fulcrum buckle, wire bail buckle with rubber belt (can be used with standard webbing but is a real PITA) and SeaQuest buckle and belt. The thinking diver will try and select the one that does the best job.

To my way of thinking, a weight belt should have a positive opening and closing buckle that permits the buckle to be opened and the belt to be removed with a minimum of motion and with just one hand. I do not feel that a buckle depending on friction meets that specification.

To the best on my knowledge the wire bail buckle and SeaQuest buckle answer all the issues that have been raised while the more conventional thread-thru buckles do not. That’s not to say “Your ‘Gonna Die” if you use the conventional buckle, but I seen enough situations in life where such buckles added “one more problem” and so I no longer use them.

As far as IW systems are concerned, if you can take the tank off and not lose buoyancy control, no problem. But if removing your tank would result in your not being able to maintain your depth or prvent you from making your stops on your buddy’s auxiliary, you might want to give that some thought. The incident detailed above in only one of many unexpected and unplanned for things that can and do happen. I have a SeaQuest Black Diamond that I like to use in the tropics with a thin suit, I never use more than 10 lbs in it, since I can swing 14 lbs on my lungs and in an emergency can ditch my tank and still maintain my buoyancy be shifting my breathing lower in my cycle.
 
I make my own rubber weight belts and they are far superior to nylon belts in my opinion. I use a stainless buckle or an old style wire loop buckle system. I suspect that people using only weight integrated BC's would hate weight belts much less if they had been exposed to rubber belts which self-adjust with depth, and don't spin around putting the buckle behind the tank.

The spring loaded buckles do not provide enough tension or "elasticity" to be useful for other than a very light weight belt in my experience.
 
Rubber weight belts are certainly the best for compensating and staying in place, but they don't always grip dependably with friction buckles.

I prefer the Marseilles style rubber belt for it's ease in use, security and quick release, as does a huge portion of the freedive market.

I bought a dozen of the Seaquest weight belts for our shop decades ago when they came out. The buckle is well designed but they did not sell. The buckle makes weight placement, and removal very difficult. It also does not compensate.
It was also quite expensive as I recall.

Chad
 
Wouldn't a harness system like the DUI Weight and Trim solve all these issues, plus allow better air transfer in drysuits?
 
O2BBubbleFree:
Wouldn't a harness system like the DUI Weight and Trim solve all these issues, plus allow better air transfer in drysuits?

The DUI harness solves just about all issues with weight belts IMO (I dive one, so I am of course biased).

However, it also introduces a problem given that you can not remove the system easily to while in the water without getting out of the rest of your gear first. This would be a problem if using a dive kayak for instance.

Harness systems are still vastly superior to belts IMO.

Just my $0.02
 
Now my curiousity is piqued... where does one find one of these "Marseilles style rubber belts" used by freedivers? I don't know that I would change, as I am happy with my XS pocket belt with SS buckle, but I'd still like to read up on it.
 
Thalassamania:
Would you believe Amazon.com?

LOL nice, that'll teach me. I see it actually comes from LeisurePro.

I actually did some searching on the net and came across a spearfishing board that pointed me to a shop in Austin that has that one plus a similar one for less:

http://www.austinsdiving.com/weightbelts/

It's somewhat tempting to pick one up, put the slide-on pockets from my XS pocket belt on it and see how it does.
 
I actually have the wire belt shown above and use it mostly for freediving. I have had trouble with that type of buckle getting caught on the bottom while scuba diving for lobsters and poping open unexpectedly.... I think that type is the absolute safest for freediving however, because it is the easiest to ditch. Either belt will be much more comfortable than a normal nylon belt!
 

Back
Top Bottom