2airishuman
Contributor
HP 100 sounds the way I should be going then. I mostly do and will be doing shore dives, sometimes with decent surface swims to the site but not anything extreme.
Most people I go with are using AL80's so I thought like you said, it might just be a waste of air and weight to always lug around.
I'm 5'8" 170lbs so the 100 sounds a bit better of a choice for weight too.
HP100s are a better deal than AL80s in nearly every way except purchase price and are what I would suggest. They are 7.25" diameter while your HP119 is 8" so be aware that you will have to readjust cambands whenever you switch tanks. For most people this isn't a big deal.
A fact to be aware of is that, in my experience, most dive shops will short fill HP cylinders unless you insist that they fill them properly. Two reasons for this. First is that HP steels will warm up enough during the fill that they either have to be filled to a higher pressure to compensate for the temperature (perfectly legal and safe but most dive shops won't do it), or they have to be allowed to cool down for about an hour and then topped off. The second reason is that many shops run their air storage system at 3500 PSI, because some compressors wear more quickly at higher pressures and because some shops don't want to push their storage bottles beyond that point. If they do that, well, they can't give you a full 3442 PSI fill without starting the compressor, which they try to avoid.
When I pick up cylinders, I use a tank checker and check them, and ask for a top-off if they are below 3350. Any shop that provides fills will have a tank checker that you can borrow for the purpose.