Another women seriously injured by whale - Australia

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

DandyDon

Umbraphile
ScubaBoard Supporter
Messages
54,106
Reaction score
8,254
Location
One kilometer high on the Texas Central Plains
# of dives
500 - 999
And can't wait to do it again...!

Woman seriously hurt by whale days after diver crushed at same beauty spot
A WOMAN has been badly injured by a 30 tonne humpback whale just days after another diver was crushed by two of the giants at the same Australian beauty spot.
Alicia Ramsey was taking part in the Ningaloo Discovery Whale Shark snorkelling tour when her group encountered a huge female humpback and her calf.
Alicia Ramsey suffered internal injuries after being hit by one of the humpack whale's fins.
Ms Ramsey, who is from Perth, said the calf swam near her group and its protective mother then lashed out with one of her massive fins, reports 9News.
The force seriously damaged the snorkeller's ribs and barnacles on the humpback grazed her skin.
She was taken to Exmouth Hospital, in Western Australia, before being airlifted to the trauma ward at Royal Perth Hospital for treatment.
Doctors said her internal injuries were like she had been "hit by a car."
The incident comes just a week after a diver suffered shocking injuries when she was crushed by two humpbacks in a "freak accident" at the same spot.
Humpback whales can reach 16 metres in length and weigh up to 30 tonnes.
The 29-year-old was left with fractured ribs and internal bleeding after becoming sandwiched between the giants at Ningaloo Reef, on the North West Cape.
Ms Ramsey, 30, said: "The calf decided to come check us out and ended up being between us and the mum so mum went into protective mode and swung back.
"As she did that to put herself between us and the calf her fin came out and got me."
Ms Ramsey said she didn't realise the full extent of her injuries until she was back on the boat.
She said: "For it to be the second one in a week I cannot believe it happened to me.
"It felt like somebody had punched me," she added from her hospital bed.
Dr Sheryl Jonescu said: "We certainly have seen some injuries which are consistent with those people that have been hit by a car."
Despite her ordeal Ms Ramsey said she can't wait to go back into the water to encounter more marine giants.
"I will go back and do it again, " she said.
 
Are there programs like this elsewhere that have been successful? Seems like the calves are always going to be curious and move in...I've seen a couple videos from NZ where orca calves join swimmers, with the calf's mum nearby. The drone video shows how quickly the calves can move.

 
What do they mean by 'beauty spot'? Aka...Beautiful location?
 
Are there programs like this elsewhere that have been successful? Seems like the calves are always going to be curious and move in...I've seen a couple videos from NZ where orca calves join swimmers, with the calf's mum nearby. The drone video shows how quickly the calves can move.


Silver Banks, but that is the humpback migration and they are very cautious about when they put snorkelers in the water.
 
I'd love to see a whale as close as possible from a boat, but I'm sold on not diving with them now.
 
Are there programs like this elsewhere that have been successful? Seems like the calves are always going to be curious and move in...I've seen a couple videos from NZ where orca calves join swimmers, with the calf's mum nearby. The drone video shows how quickly the calves can move.

Its a big part of why many Australian and NZ divers visit Tonga, we did an impromptu snorkel with a whale and her calf enroute back from a dive, amazing experience I'll remember for the rest of my life.
https://www.tongawhaleswim.com/
 
Its a big part of why many Australian and NZ divers visit Tonga, we did an impromptu snorkel with a whale and her calf enroute back from a dive, amazing experience I'll remember for the rest of my life.
https://www.tongawhaleswim.com/

Tonga and Moorea are the two other places besides Western Australia I'm aware of where they do humpback whale swims. I did Moorea last September with a small tour group (6 guests, 1 guide). We saw one male singer that stayed deep, two mom-and-calf pairs, one mom with a calf and a male escort, and a heat run of four males in hot pursuit of a female. The last bit was probably the closest call we had as the five adults all surfaced right around us, but I don't think they got within 20-30 ft of anyone.

I'm not aware that they've had any whale-induced injuries to people, although with at last check 21 operators and 33 boats it is getting overcrowded. Hopefully this year the whales are getting a break, although the smaller operators got clobbered by the travel shutdowns into FP. Around the time we were there they had one calf known as "Crazy Baby" or "Kamikaze;" she was infamous for coming right up to snorkelers and according to one guide the mother just let her - almost like "here, you take this damn kid, I'm exhausted." However, reportedly they left for the duration of our stay because some rube on another boat ignored the lecture and dove down on the calf.

 
Crap "journalism" but yes beauty spot would mean in this context scenic region although its a little more than that...Ningaloo Reef has been the resident birthing and migratory grounds for humpbacks, whale sharks and Bill fish along with resident manta, dugong and turtle nesting grounds for ever. Its Unesco listed Marine Heritage Park and one of the biggest fringing reefs in the world.
This is the second or third year of a pilot programme modelled on the Tonga operation but with greater distances between vessels and whales and swimmers and whales. The first time it happened the operator said it had never happened before and was unlikely to every happen again but stressed with any interaction with wild animals there are inherent dangers. There are no tours scheduled for this week due to weather and id hazard a guess a meeting will take place between the licence holder, fisheries dept, tourism dept and other relevant parties.

My off the cuff guess is this is the same mum and calf involved in the first incident. Obviously one of those helicopter parents/first time mum who hasn't got to the stage of look after this kid its driving me nuts yet. Footage will show if it is, and this calf is well over "safe" age by its size, and given the millions of $$$ invested in the program id say risk mitigation strategies involving that whale will be implemented.
 
It's all harassment. No the mother/calf pairs aren't "playing with you." They are stuck at the surface, because the calf can't dive away from danger yet. Mommy is not playing. She's is worried and she is pissed off. The boat ops are clearly taking advantage of this. There's even a proper scientific study showing this
 

Back
Top Bottom