Forgot you were asking about AKR - loved them, but for a non-diver, the Palace in Cozumel would be much better. Better amenities, food, drinks, location (if you want to go outside of the resort for shopping or local dining).
We stayed at the Coz Palace this March and it was FABULOUS. I just didn't like having to sit in the boat for 20 minutes once through with a dive. My wife elected to watch our nephew as my Dad and stepmom were with us and the stepmom was diving with me. Yes, the amenities there satisfy my wife completely. Will be looking into the Hilton for Christmas in DR but if all 3 islands are neck and neck with when they open I may opt for Roatan or Bonaire. DR may be something we take seriously a little later on once everything opens up. Am I right in saying DR is currently closed bc of COVID 19?