ANYONE can make a mistake and rent faulty equipment they THOUGHT would perform. What makes one shop better than another is WHAT THEY DO AFTER THE MISTAKE HAS BEEN BROUGHT TO THEIR ATTENTION. In this case, in my opinon, they could have done FAR more than they have.
Safe Diving!
BINGO! The dive was on Saturday and I didn't post this until later yesterday. Reason? As I originally stated, the weight thing is clearly debatable. And, equipment failures can and do happen. I was giving the shop the benefit of the doubt until I heard back on how they handled this. When I heard that they blamed her, I quickly concluded that this is a shop divers need to be aware of. Where there is smoke, there is fire. A few people have pointed out that the diver should have put the reg on a cylinder and checked it before departing. Maybe I missed a post or two, but I didn't see anyone say the shop should have done the same. The few times I rented gear, I didn't even have a chance to test the gear myself because an employee assembled it right in front of me and tested it. That way, we both saw that it was operating correctly. I think it's bad enough that the shop rented this gear in the first place, but to not even accept responsibility for it when they were told it failed is totally inexcusable in my book. This is not the type of shop I want my friends or any of my dive buddies getting anything from. Beyond that, with all of the wonderful dive shops around here (many of which are struggling right now with the slowed down economy), I hate to see a shop like this get a single "dive dollar". I'd much rather see our diving money spent at shops that care more about their customers than this one seemingly does.