I voted yes (for lack of yes, but...)
I had an opportunity several years ago to go on the Pac Star. A girlfriend DM'd for the boat. I was poor at the time and, if memory serves, I didn't have the cash. Hindsight tells me it was a good choice not to go. I was a relatively new diver with my "advanced" cards & such. I was clueless about detailed safety procedures such as outlined by Chuck. My buddies (again in hindsight) would have been inadequate. Lisa came back and wouldn't let me live down how great the diving was. Oh well. The islands will still be there when I'm ready.
Would I go tomorrow? No. Been outta the water for a while and need to get back in practice.
Why would I EVER want to go? Just look at the pics. I'm not afraid of sharks. I figure we're just as likely to run into one at Breakwater (OK, maybe the chances are greater in the Red Triangle, but you know...) Even so, you wouldn't find me bobbing on the surface for too long.
My scariest diving experiences have been on the commute to and from Monterey.