murdrcycle:My computer says 20 ft, my class (and many divers here) said 33 ft, but the truth is that any time we breath underwater regardless of depth we are taking on excess nitrogen?
This is all based on Haldanean modeling. At any depth below 1 atm (14.7psi) you will have additional nitrogen loading. At the surface at a baometric pressure of 14.7 psi your body cannot absorb any more nitrogen based on this pressure...In effect we are saturated with nitrogen at this pressure. If you go to 1ft below the surface, even though it is an extremely small amount, you are in fact absorbing more nitrogen. Thing is, again dealing with Haldane and compartment theory, above 20 feet you will never exceed the maximum allowable loading of any compartment no matter how long you stay, which is why you will not suffer DCS at 20 ft or above.
Conclusions regarding safety stops had to do with research using Doppler to detect bubbles in the bloodstream. It was found that a safety stop for 1 minute at 20 feet and 4 minutes at 10 feet had the lowest detection of bubble via Doppler. As far as the 3 minute safety stop at 15 feet I assume they found a compromise depth that still showed hardly any detectable bubbles via Doppler, i.e...for simplicity. It is easier to stay at 15 ft than at 10 feet and you only have one stop at 15 ft compared to a 1 minute stop at 20 ft followed by a 4 minute stop at 10 ft.
Research also showed that even though a slower ascent rate of 30 ft/minute did reduce nitrogen loading as compared to an ascent rate of 60 ft/minute both results were still much higher than doing a safety stop at 15 ft for 3 minutes