Acerb29
Pro Dive and Halls are both excellent schools. While not a graduate of either, over the past 30 years I have been diving with and spoken at length with graduates of both. I hold both Naui and Padi certifications so I don’t have an automatic bias… I have talked to both recently about continuing education… you will not regret either choice.
Rather than worrying about “which is the better school,” focus on "which is the better fit for you." If you are going to own your own hometown dive shop, your answer may be very different than if your dream is to work at Stuart’s Cove or serve as a dive officer on a yacht. Here are some questions you should ask yourself.
1. What agency do you want to work for after graduation? If you are planning on going Naui, Halls is clearly your choice. If Padi, Prodive is a better fit.
2. Where do you want to work? Poll the dive shops/resorts in your chosen employment locations and see if there are a large number of potential employers who hire instructors from your agency of choice (#1 above). If employment in a specific location or region is your goal, the answer to this question should be one of the, if not the most important. Do not rely on the schools to tell you what the market is. They all claim 100% placement and have statistics to back it up… The question you should be interested in isn’t “will you get a job” but “will you get a job where you want to be.” If the rather than dry land you answer is serving on a yacht, Pro Dive is definitely the better choice. Fort Lauderdale is home to several of the world’s largest schools for yacht crews… At Pro Dive you can dual track -- do both your scuba and yacht programs simultaneously -- and be ready to step right onto a yacht the day after graduation. Dive officer on a yacht is for singles only unless your spouse is also in the industry (you are always on the move and seldom in one location very long), but you get to see the world, meet amazingly successful people (the owners and guests on yachts are not dull, boring and average!) and the starting pay on yachts is close to double what resort based instructors get. Do you want to start your career in one small private corner of paradise or see it all and then choose?
3. Are you a city person or more quiet and laidback? What do you plan on doing when you are not in class or diving? Marathon is relatively quiet and remote. The population is somewhere around 10,000. Fort Lauderdale on the other hand is a real city with all the pluses and minuses. If you like kicking back and being completely off the radar screen, Halls might be a good fit. If you are more into the city scene (beachfront, malls, movie theaters, parties, libraries, museums etc.), then you should lean toward ProDive. There is no right answer… Just what is right for you.
4. Marital status. Single looking to hook up… Fort Lauderdale. Married looking for a second honeymoon… Marathon. Married and spouse needs to find a job… Fort Lauderdale.
5. Toys and special programs. Over the next 6-8 weeks Pro Dive is opening year round demo centers for dry suits, underwater cameras, dpv’s, full face masks with communications and underwater video. It is simply going to be the best place in the world to play with scuba toys and pick up specialty certifications. On the other hand, Halls has a rebreather instructor program (are you a tech diver?). Pro Dive does not. Then again, Pro Dive has the only program (“ROS”

where every graduate is certified as both a Reef Check instructor and an instructor of underwater photography… And so the list of pros and cons goes on and on. Which brings us back to “which is a better fit for you?”
Most importantly, if you are the least bit unsure, visit them both, meet the staffs, check out their boats, look at the local accommodations, and see which is the place you want to make home for the weeks or months you are taking your courses!
Hope this helps... let us know where you decide to go!
P