CODMAN and Centrals are absolutely right - PG is as seedy as you want it to be, and so would anywhere else be really!
A few of us were in PG last May and I stayed in Small La Laguna, the small stretch in between Sabang and Big La Laguna. It was peaceful and quiet at night, no thumping music etc. All the dive sites were pretty much 5-10 mins away, and we even did several shore entry dives which imo was pretty cool since I don't get them too often. There's a very good variety of diving there - wrecks, wall, macro, drift.. and the night dives were great too!
It was an easy 10 minute stroll down to Sabang and we were never uncomfortable having dinner and/or drinks there some of the nights. We hung out mainly along the main stretch and most of most of the girly bars and discos were located in the street/alley behind and they weren't overly aggressive or in your face. :cool3:
We also hired a banca ride to white beach which is the more lively area with plenty of bars/ restaurants - this area is always populated and has a very good, fun vibe to it. There are plenty of accommodation choices here as well but just take note it isn't as close (as Big/Small LL, Sabang is) to most of the main dive sites.
There's even a proper shooting range in PG if you want to do something different! We never made it there.. after 3 full days of diving
I would definitely go back to PG again, everything was so relaxed and easy. But this year May I am going to Malapascua!!! Matt from Evolution has been so lovely and patient, answering my 1001 questions (sry Matt!) and helping me sort out our accomo and diving arrangements!
PG and Malapascua both have a good variety of dive sites and have a chilled/laidback vibe as well, so I'm sure you'll have a blast whichever place you end up choosing - Me, I'm just counting down to end of May, who knows maybe we might see each other in Malapascua! :snorkel2: