But you can do the same in Bonaire, i.e. get an accurate picture of the crime scene in Bonaire from internet resources. Do a simple search for "bonaire theft" and start reading. It's not like it's a big secret, even though the Tourist Board might not advertise it as they do the shore diving.
Even the State Dept. has something to say: "Street crime remains a concern, especially in St. Maarten. Valuables, including passports, left unattended on beaches, in cars, and hotel lobbies are easy targets for theft, Visitors should leave valuables and personal papers secured in their hotel. Burglary and break-ins are increasingly common at resorts, beach houses, and hotels. Armed robbery occasionally occurs. The American boating community has reported a handful of incidents in the past, and visitors are urged to exercise reasonable caution in securing boats and belongings. Car theft, especially of rental vehicles, can occur. Incidents of break-ins to rental cars to steal personal items have been reported by American tourists. Vehicle leases or rentals may not be fully covered by local insurance when a vehicle is stolen. Be sure you are sufficiently insured when renting vehicles and other equipment."
Of course the State Dept. makes out almost every foreign destination to be as dangerous as Baghdad or Miami, so if we listened to them we'd stay home in our bomb shelters. The vast majority of travelers to Bonaire that follow the standard rental car admonition to not leave anything valuable inside end up having a wonderful time without any incidents. It's a simple rule to follow, much like "don't drink the water" when you travel to Mexico. Yes, plenty of people still end up with turista in Mexico, and plenty of people still suffer some kind of theft on Bonaire, but it's a lot easier to make water potable than it is to make people honest. When Mexico fixes its water issues, then maybe Bonaire will get around to fixing its crime. In the meantime, we just have to respect the foreign culture and not impose our American standards on every country we visit. If Mexicans like contaminated water and Bonaireans like petty theft and French like prostitutes and Netherlanders like marijuana, who are we to say this is necessarily the wrong way to do things just because we tend to frown on all of the above in our own land?