Found my bill of sale, turns out the BCD is less than 2 years old. I took my BCD to the LDS again, explained what was going on with the numerous occurences of a stuck inflator.
You guys are correct. I unscrewed a new, on the rack, Zeagle BCD and you can easily see the return spring. My spring appeared to be a thinner gauge of metal and slightly bent within the inflator housing compared to the new one. This could be a usage thing, I don't know. Only 88 dives total though. The LDS then said Zeagle was aware and replacing the "older" springs with a new stronger spring to solve the problem. It should be under warranty, so it's all good so far. We'll see what the end result will be.
It's always about what I've learned. ( in order to pass it on ) I don't think I have been screwing the inflator on too tightly ( to bend the valve ) as the LDS said Zeagle is aware of the issue with the older springs. I've also learned soaking the inflator over night in fresh water doesn't really do anything. This also includes holding the inflate and deflate buttons open while swishing the fresh water inside. What you need to do is attach the inflator to a garden hose ( similar to what I can do when I flush the BCD bladders ), hold open the inflate / deflate buttons at various times to really give it a good flush. This is what the LDS now suggests.
Should be operational again soon, hopefully at no charge. Will let you know how it turns out. Thanks again.