Strongly considering solo diving - lets talk

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

It would seem the majority of people in this discussion feel Solo diving is fine, given certain criteria. All seem to feel a buddy is more risk than safety.

For you who feel a buddy is important how about relating some instances where a buddy helped with a bad situation. I know this requires admitting a mistake but I never see threads on “How My Buddy Helped Me”.
 
For you who feel a buddy is important how about relating some instances where a buddy helped with a bad situation. I know this requires admitting a mistake but I never see threads on “How My Buddy Helped Me”.[/QUOTE]


That seems like a good question and, as much as polls suck, it might be more suited to poll form for reasons of anonymity.
 
mjh:
For you who feel a buddy is important how about relating some instances where a buddy helped with a bad situation. I know this requires admitting a mistake but I never see threads on “How My Buddy Helped Me”.
There I was barely above the mud, scooting along the length of a log looking underneath it for an octopus. I saw a flicker of light in front of me pointing out the loop of rope I was about to swim into. Thanks to the warning, my buddy didn't have to untangle me :D
 
ElectricZombie:
The simple solution is to find a good DIR buddy. Practice w/ this person and just dive with them. <snip> I still think your best bet is trying to find another DIR diver (or convert someone...lol) and just dive with them.

I never have more fun that I do when I'm diving with Arnaud... the current DIR buddy. We hooked up this summer, and even the bad trips are tolerable, and the good trips become great.

Still noodling on this. Thanks to all for the great discussion.

K
 
Solo diving...

what is solodiving and why would you want to ?
I leave those questions for someone else to answer..

I have tried to read all of the things ppl have said about it in this thread..
and have some things to say.

First of all the things about having two gears instead of one makes for double chance of critical equipment faliure.
well I think you mean regulators and stuff. that equipment is not critical any more since you have two, yours and your buddys.
so to have a CRITICAL equipment to faliure you must fail BOTH first stages not only one and so on,
so that point is total crap not thought through properly. in my humble opinion.

2nd point Uncle pug states no doubles since an oring may burst..
that is also totally wrong according to me:
(would like to state first that I have the outmost respect for pug)
since if you are using doubles with manifold and have a valve on the manifold (total of three knobs) to shutdown the flow inbetween the two bottles and regulators the only time I can se that you are equally or worse off with doubles than with a single tank is when you hammer in to something and totalls the manifold or valve on the manifold, then you have a bad bad faliure wich would equal blowing a burst disc or an oring on a single.
otherwise you will always be able to shutdown the offending regulator/bottle wich means you can turn the dive and finish in a safer fashion than directly heading for the surface..

can we agree that basically anything is better than a single?
doubles, independant doubles, pony bottles, buddy, etc etc.. I would prefer a "spair air" to nothing.. ANY "air" is better than no "air"

Third the point someone makes to wheather or not the risk of not coming home to your loved ones..
If I die becouse of I got hit by a car, or that I drowned. I dont think my loved ones would feel any different from wich ever happened.
and if you are living by your rule you wouldnt go anywhere and do nothing since nothing is worth beeing separated from your lovedones, in wich case you are already "dead". if that is the case, I truly pity you.
as far as I know we only have one life, LIVE IT !!!!
do not stop thinking about the fact that you can die, but live life so that when you die wich we most likely will do some day, when that day comes you can say I made most of my life.. and I made a positive difference to someone else...

now on to the original question.
IF you are going solodiving,
I personally think that then you need VERY GOOD GEAR, fx you dont want a crap octo, the backup shouldnt be worse than your primary
I think you get the point

Do not use "rentalgear", be familiar to how everything works, and that it fits you, this is very very important..
it might be easy when you are relaxed, but when the **** hits the fan you better know how things work and all the little quirks that can go wrong.. fx the bcd is slow or very fast to let the air in or out... stuff like that..

dont go totally alone, have someone know where you are atleast, over the phone or something and have a schedule to follow, you will contact them in X ammount of minutes.. then atleast someone will know where you are and be able to contact rescue.. or better off bring someone with you. If you have the money bring two phones (fully charged)..
a cellphone is not that expensive today.. one with you and one in the car/boat/bech..
if one gets destroyed in the water, or you come up somewhere totally different from your intentions, I use a drysuit so I have a phone with me (yes i have gotten sms at 40 meters deapth it works...) and some identification papers (wich doesnt get destroyed if they get wet), I leave a letter stating who to contact and so on..practice getting all gear off in the water moving as little as possible, with help of friends snag yourself in a pool and practice getting out of both your equipment and the snag..have many cutting tools, I use a knife a pair of siccors and a line cutter..
I use doubles with manifold and a shutdown valve since i think its the best solution for me..

streamline yourself you dont want to snag if you can avoid it ;-)

be aware..

there is most likely many other things i have missed please feel free to inform me of my mistakes.. and errors..

and for anyone whose toes I have stepped upon I am truly sorry...
 
ElectricZombie:
This is the best argument for solo diving; lack of a decent buddy.
...
The simple solution is to find a good DIR buddy.
It's a personal choice each diver has to make.
I would rather dive with a good buddy than a less-than-reliable one, though I'll dive with anyone who asks.
I would rather dive with a buddy than dive solo.
I would rather dive solo than not dive at all.

I have yet to find a DIR buddy here, but I have found a couple of good non-DIR buddies. One of them I can sometimes even talk into practicing skills - especially since he recently got full cave certified.
 
Snowbear:
I would rather dive with a good buddy than a less-than-reliable one, though I'll dive with anyone who asks.
I would rather dive with a buddy than dive solo.
I would rather dive solo than not dive at all.
I would rather dive with a buddy better than me so I can learn from their superior skills.
I would rather dive with a good buddy than a less-than-reliable one, though I'll dive with anyone who asks.
I would rather dive with a buddy than dive solo. Sometimes.
I would rather dive solo then with a buddy. Sometimes.
I would rather dive solo than not dive at all.
 

Back
Top Bottom