Strobe too strong for Makro Solution ??

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Immeriswas

Contributor
Messages
128
Reaction score
112
Location
Germany
# of dives
500 - 999
Got myself a Utramax strobe for my Canon Ixus 105 with Ikelite housing to get a better performance in the macro distance ( the inbuild strobe only lights the upper left corner, if you get closer then 20 cm ). But even with the lowest setting of 20 %power the macropictures were everytime totally overexposed. Tried different cameraprograms and the only manuell setting of -2 (max ) exposingcorrektion-didn`t work. So in the end I tried to point the strobe beside the objekt to reduce the amount of light, which was very tricky. For wide angle the strobe works very well. Would appriciate any suggestions for this problem.
 
Maybe try a diffuser?
 
Or a longer arm? With the built in flash lighting the top left, you could try positioning the strobe on a longer arm on the right. The light will fall off noticeably within a few feet.

For some macro (coral polyps) I place my strobes very close. For others I position them as far away as possible so that I get more shadows.

How long is your arm?
 
Sounds like what you need is a solid evening spent reading the Strobist blog! It really helped me understand the principles of lighting with strobes.

There are 4 things you can do to adjust exposure. First is strobe power, which you can control by a knob on the strobe, or by moving the strobe further away, etc. Second is ISO, but usually this is used when you want a lighter shot, but if you are shooting with a high ISO, you can drop it down nice and low for macro work, such as iso100.

The next thing is shutter speed, which when you are using a strobe, really controls the "background" or ambient light in the shot.

The last thing is aperture. The reason you control the strobe light by aperture and the ambient light with the shutter is due to how fast the strobe fires. Lets say that the sun is throwing 100 units of light per second at your camera. So, by a half second exposure, you get 50 light units. The sun is constant as far as the camera is concerned, so you control the portion of light from the sun by changing how long the shutter stays open.

However, strobes fire super, super fast, lets call it a thousandth of a second. So, if your strobe fires 100 light units, and you have a half second exposure, as long as the strobe fires during that half second, because it fires so fast, all 100 light units will get in the camera.

It sounds like you aren't using TTL, since then your camera should quench the strobe and keep your exposures decent. If you are shooting manual, it is not uncommon to shoot with a shutter speed of 1/60 to 1/125 (if your subject moves or is blurry, try to go faster, if you want the background to be bluer from natural sunlight, you go slower) and an aperture of f16, 18, 20, 22, etc. Today, I was shooting at f32, with my strobes on full. It all depends on the situation.

Your camera should be able to fire a few test shots on land without harming the strobe. It can overheat if you shoot too rapidly, just like any strobe or speedlight. Set up in a dim room some kids toy or something, and try taking some pictures to practice.

Lastly, shoot in raw if at all possible. It won't fix truly over or under exposed pictures, which contain no data at all in those pixels, but it will let you fix minorly off shots.
 
Thanks a lot for your suggestions. I tried the strobe before diving in a dark room and was alreaedy aware of the too much power problem. The arm is around 40 cm long (i could remove the strobe away during the dive to hold it further away but that was very comlicated, the strobe is on the left side because the inbuild flash, whiches is capped towards the front fires the external one ( no TTL ) Unfortunatly the -2 setting for exposure is the only manual setting option i have. ISO is on 80, so at least that sounds ok. The diffuser is already in use. Maybe i put some semitransparent foil over the difuser to weeken the light ?
 
You could try a neutral density filter if your camera can take a filter. You could even cut a disk of this and put it under your diffuser. Try a theatrical supply store to source this material.

Another alternative might be to cut some wedges of electrical tape and apply those to your diffuser. This would block the strobe output partially and could possibly be adjusted underwater.
 
The neutral density filter sounds interesting. Got a friend working at the local theater. Will asked him for a sample to try that out. Thanks gert7to3
 
What camera are you using?
 
a canon ixus 110 is compact camera with no real manual settings, only the -2 to +2 exposure correction
 

Back
Top Bottom