halemanō;5735236:
That part I bolded above seems pertinent for this thread also.
The reason I asked you "what temp" is because I
specifically asked for examples
in the conditions set by the OP; which included "
warm water."
You are nit picking.
You asked for examples of hardware failures that could happen in the conditions described by the OP. I gave several.
I also said that I have never had any of these failures except a free flowing reg. This was not particularly aimed at responding to your question, but a comment that I have had a reg free flow and didn't need the pony as I was near the surface when it happened.
Cold water is one, and the most likely cause of a free flowing reg, but it is not the only one - it is possible to have a reg fail and free flow in warm water. Just much less likely.
It is possible to add content to a thread that does not directly address your concerns. It's not all about you.
I didn't pay attention to the temperature at the time I was diving because it wasn't particularly important. It was a local dive, at a spot that I have been diving for roughly 30 years (I did my first OW dive at that location) and the temperature on that particular day was not unusual in any way. The reg was the problem - not the cold water, it was a crap reg and I regret buying it.
You don't dive with a pony, I do, for the reasons stated. You don't, as I understand it, because you don't belive that it solves anything you can't solve without one. You evaluate the risks and conclude that a pony is not needed. I evaluate the risks and think that for me it is. I don't want some piece of hardware failing at depth on a multi dive day without some kind of redundant air supply that will allow slower controlled ascent. You may be comfortable doing a CESA on the 4th dive of the day on the fourth day of a four or five dives a day diving but I am not.