For many years, I dive the Mares Avanti Quattro in both wet and dry-suit. When I took my recreational Wreck Diver class, my instructor highly recommended to get new fins with a shorter blade, which are more suitable for wreck diving. Now I consider to go further on the wreck diving path, starting with the Advanced Nitrox & Deco. That implies training the different fin kicks. So, I am looking for a new pair of fins that are
- shorter than the Avanti Quattro
- good for fin-kick training
- Beginner's Fins: Following the comments from other threads, rubber fins (eg. original Scubapro) are a little softer than the more rigid plastic fins (OMS Slipstream, deep6 Eddy). For a beginner like me, who still needs to build up his muscles, this would slightly favor the rubber fins. (I do not expect the difference to be huge.) Other manufacturer provide up to three different hardness or stiffness, there must be a reason why.
- Foot pocket: Most of the clones have a better shaped foot pocket than the original made from rubber, but the less flexible plastic material seems to cancel that advantage. For example, some users report a pain on the instep after long dives (1 hour plus). On the other hand, choosing the right size for a Scubapro is apparently some sort of gambling, some years ago the sizes were changed (new XL added, old XL is current XXL). But, another point for the original Scubapro.
- Buoyancy: Sometimes, a negatively buoyant fin is useful to compensate for a top-heavy trim. For me this is no issue.
- Weight: The original Scubapro's can be twice as heavy as a lightweight clone. When travelling by plane, weight is an issue. One point for the ligther clones.
- Length: The true Jet-Fin clones have almost the same length. Just for the sake of completeness, the length criterion rules out other tech fins. For example, the Apeks RK3 is n terms of length half way between the Jet Fin and the Avanti Quattro.
- Quality, straps: Spring straps are the established standard. Hard to find anything else on the market. Quality may be different with colored models (less resistant to sun light). Pure rubber fins are cast in one piece, the other materials might be composed. But I doubt there is an effect besides marketing talk.