A couple thoughts/corrections.
1. Aluminum SCBA tanks just like aluminum scuba tanks are not life limited. In contrast hoop wrapped composite SCBA tanks (and scuba tanks) are life limited with a 15 year life span. Luxfer makes a 4000 psi hoop wrapped scuba tank - in essence an AL 80 with a carbon fiber over wrap to increase service pressure and volume. But like SCBA tanks, any damage to the outer wrap and resin that protects the wrap will let water into the wrap and will result in the tank being condemned. So at best, they are a bit fragile by scuba tank standards and less than ideal for use underwater. The same limits apply to SCBA tanks that while they may get wet, are not used under water.
2. Another issue with SCBA tanks is that light weight matter, buoyancy traits do not, so they are often too floaty for efficient use as scuba tanks. This is especially the case with hoop wrapped composite tanks.
3. And, in practice SCBA tanks tend to be slam filled going from empty to full in maybe 30-45 seconds in some fire departments. They basically refill the tank on the firemans back out of an air bank on the truck rather than swapping tanks and filling the tank slower and/or later. I have not been around the hydro business for about 5 years now, but I noted a high number of aluminum SCBA tanks with neck cracks and the general opinion was this had a lot to do with the slam fill practices used in the departments these tanks came from. So buyer beware.
4. Finally, there is the valve issue. SCBA and scuba tanks use different threads and DOT regs allow no modification of the threads, even chasing them with a tap to "fix" damaged threads. So at best you have to use an adapter and that is a less than elegant solution and just adds additional points for a leak could occur and may create some discomfort with the reg hitting you in the head.
1. Aluminum SCBA tanks just like aluminum scuba tanks are not life limited. In contrast hoop wrapped composite SCBA tanks (and scuba tanks) are life limited with a 15 year life span. Luxfer makes a 4000 psi hoop wrapped scuba tank - in essence an AL 80 with a carbon fiber over wrap to increase service pressure and volume. But like SCBA tanks, any damage to the outer wrap and resin that protects the wrap will let water into the wrap and will result in the tank being condemned. So at best, they are a bit fragile by scuba tank standards and less than ideal for use underwater. The same limits apply to SCBA tanks that while they may get wet, are not used under water.
2. Another issue with SCBA tanks is that light weight matter, buoyancy traits do not, so they are often too floaty for efficient use as scuba tanks. This is especially the case with hoop wrapped composite tanks.
3. And, in practice SCBA tanks tend to be slam filled going from empty to full in maybe 30-45 seconds in some fire departments. They basically refill the tank on the firemans back out of an air bank on the truck rather than swapping tanks and filling the tank slower and/or later. I have not been around the hydro business for about 5 years now, but I noted a high number of aluminum SCBA tanks with neck cracks and the general opinion was this had a lot to do with the slam fill practices used in the departments these tanks came from. So buyer beware.
4. Finally, there is the valve issue. SCBA and scuba tanks use different threads and DOT regs allow no modification of the threads, even chasing them with a tap to "fix" damaged threads. So at best you have to use an adapter and that is a less than elegant solution and just adds additional points for a leak could occur and may create some discomfort with the reg hitting you in the head.