roatan or bonaire in september

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

cba191

Contributor
Messages
70
Reaction score
0
Location
Salt Lake City
# of dives
25 - 49
i am new to diving and want to go to the caribbean. i think i've narrowed it down to roatan and bonaire. advantages or disadvantages for either? i'll be going to hawaii in august, so i'll have a few dives under my belt. if it matters, i'll probably be going solo.
thanks,
ben
 
Someone else can answer the Bonaire side of the question, as I have not been there yet, but these are my thoughts on Roatan.

My wife and I really like Roatan. We've been there twice and plan to return again this fall. I would recommend Roatan to anyone interested in a relaxed atmosphere vacation with a strong focus on diving. If you are looking for a caribbean vacation and are expecting something like you see on television (Jamaica, Bahamas, etc) you will probably not be happy in Roatan. If you are interested in a more rugged dive destination, Roatan fits the bill perfectly.

Roatan simply has not received the attention that most Caribbean islands have outside of the diving community. It remains much less developed than the more popular "vacation" islands, although this is changing everyday. I'd suggest Roatan if for no other reason than to get a chance to enjoy it now before the cruise ships and big money finish the job of destroying the beauty and isolation that has defined it for so long.
 
I've been to both several times, to me it's no contest, Bonaire wins by a mile. The diving "freedom" is hard to beat. There is plenty of non-diving activities, more divesites then you can hit in a week of hard diving and CONSISTENT dive conditions. There is a reason that Bonaire is usually voted in as a top Carib. destination.
 
To be fair I am a big Bonaire fan but I would have to say Bonaire in Sept for one reason- hurricanes. Late Sept is in the heart of hurricane season. Bonaire is below the hurricane belt and almost never has any problems with hurricanes. When it does, it's rain and the back wash from waves which usually does not last more than 1 day. Roatan can get the full impact of hurricanes...I was there when Wilma bushed us. 3 1/2 days of no diving while watching the rain pour down was no fun. I hate to think what it would have been like if it has hit.
Each has it's advantages. I have been to both places and will return to both. Any other time of the year it would be more of a decision for me but from late July to early Dec, Bonaire wins hands down......maybe having 2 dive trips hurricaned out has something to do with my decision. :)
 
I will agree and disagree with the above posts, all at the same time!

Bonaire and Roatan are certainly in my Caribbean "Top 5". Sooner or later, you're going to want to do them both... repeatedly!

Bonaire and Roatan are both well outside of the path of hurricanes. True enough, nature has and may visit both islands with a huricane, but a simple glance at any historical chart of huricane paths- you will see that neither island is much of a target. September? I could think of better times to go to the Caribbean, but you have selected two of the more 'huricane proof' locations!

Roatan, being recently in hi-speed development, it had started with a strong established 20+ year base of AI resorts that cater to US Diver requirements and mentality. As the island has exploded in the last ten years, more operations have sprung up that are set-up for the European crowd. Entirely different programs for people with different demands and needs.

Bonaire has been around a long time. It was slowly nursed into its status as a dive mecca by American divers. The place thinks, operates and moves to our tempo. True enough, lately Europeans have visited in droves (Note the KLM 747 sharing the runway with the goats!), but the die has been set on Bonaire. You can have all the diving you want, if not from your resort, then via shore diving.

Just as a general point of information, if you visit a place that carters to Europeans, you will have to struggle to get what you might think is a requirement. 3 dives a day can be problematic (much less 5 a day)at such locations. Notably Red Sea, Maldives, Mediterranian and various other pockets located around the world that welcome divers who speak German, French, Italian, Spanish and moree! It isn't bad- it's just what it is. You have to understand.

Bonaire is a delightful place, any number of pleasant comodious resorts with an accent on your automotive mobility and access to numerous shore dive sites. The diving is good for beginners as the walls are vertical and there's lots that is easy to see. Every property there is a dive resort. There are 20 restaurants that I have been to and waddled away smiling.

Roatan? You would have to be nuts to drive a car, besides- there is simply no need or use for one. 99.9% of all diving is done by boat. There are three restaurants, arguably 5 at most, that are worth bothering with. The diving is somewhat similar, but really biased towards the diver with super buoyancy and observational skills. There are some resorts with diving, there are a few real dive resorts.

Decide what kind of experience that you are looking for and then book accordingly. You will hear miriad opinions about various resorts on Roatan, but largely driven by single visit or narrow view observations.

In Bonaire, you get a room to sleep in, you can always drive to dive. Pretty much so can't go wrong. No resort in Bonaire has a shore dive worth much, better for night diving.

In Roatan, depending on what you need and expect, selection of the accomodation (be it an All Inclusive Resort or backpacker paradise), the selection of the accomodation and its access to dive-op is key to the process.

In Roatan: What quantity of diving do you desire? Are you happy with backrolls off of a small boat or were you looking for handicapped access? Do you want 5 a day with an included night dive each night- or would you rather buy ala carte at $30 per tank. Lots of choices for everyone... just not a lot of mobility.

Your "solo" requirement does mean one clear thing- the cost of your rental car in Bonaire, a true necessity there, it will be split... one way.

You are going to do both places sooner than later.
 
Bonaire's biggest draw in my opinion is the ability to easily do shore dives. Given that you are going solo you may want to do boat dives instead. This reduces the advantage for Bonaire and makes me think Roatan would be a better choce for this trp unless you can find a dive buddy before the trip.

Do go to both at some point!
 
i like the idea that cocoview in roatan will find a buddy for you. plus, it's less developed than banaire. but the shore diving looks great in bonaire
 
cba191:
i like the idea that cocoview in roatan will find a buddy for you. plus, it's less developed than banaire. but the shore diving looks great in bonaire

Interesting... Read the next two paragraphs wiith the care that they were written:

CoCoView is my "single favorite resort". It has, arguably, the best "resort based shore dive" in the Caribbean, I rank it within the top ten in the world.

Bonaire, among all of the Caribbean Islands that currently has an accessable dive infrastructure, I rate #1 as a dive destination.

__________________

Note that we're comparing a single resort to an island nation, something which I do often!

Without rehashing a previous post, understand that Roatan's CoCoView has a rabid following (I am a member) of repeat customers. These are people that travel all over the world, go to many oceans, but always return to their "home" at CCV. Why is this?

CCV has the custom boats, the dive lockers, the photo friendly op, almost handicapped accessable- it's low key and high volume diving. Once you visit there, you will use CCV as a standard by which you will judge all other dive ops. Besides the mechanical infrastructure- the buildings, the boats, the nuts and bolts- it has the serendipity of location.

The rooms are located on posts over a changing active reef. Step out your door, flop into the ocean- the "Front Yard" as it is called. In three faeet of water find the anchor chain and meander the 300 feet out to 35 feet of water where you'll find the upright and intact 140' tanker wreck, the Prince Albert. That huge hulk is also linked to a DC3 wreck and two very nice walls, all a swim away from your room.

Here's the point: One of the true joys of diving is Night Diving. If you could always be assured... if you knew- for certain, how to "get back" from your night dive- wouldn't that make most of your fears go away? That chain links the ship to your room. Aint nothing moving on you, nothing to fear- like permanent bread crumbs. (Hansel & Gretel)

CCV is, IMNSHO, the best dive resort and location on Roatan. It is not the best party place, it is not the place to dance till dawn, it is not the place for high heels and dresses at dinner. People go there to get 5 a day. No driving, no excess terrestrial movement- driving is ill advised. Just eat, sleep and dive. Roatan tries desperately to be a lot of things to a lot of people. CCV just is what it is. Dive, dive, dive.

Bonaire, the island nation, is just as good! But Bonaire should be taken as an entire island, and it is good in a different way.

You simply have not been diving in the Caribbean if you haven't made it to this crown jewel. I cant remember how many times I have been there. The trick about Bonaire is that there is no one single stand out resort for people intent on remaining wet 24/7. You do this on your own. Do the morning boat dives- then venture off and glory in the wonderful shore dive possibilities. Driving in Bonaire is some of the safest you'll find in the Caribbean. Watch out for the donkeys (especially at night) and the cactus thorns that can pop tires. If all Caribbean islands were this safe and easy to get around!

Bonaire, unlike Roatan, also features many restauarnts. Most divers just do the well lit establishments in town. I hope you'll follow my exhortations and will venture out into the island and find the many local joints that are just a friendly delight! Don't be scared, be adventurous! Go in, have a beer, ask questions, order up! Before you turn up your nose- try the goat stew! Fabulous! Seek out the Indonesian "Rice Table" place. Yummy!

Wherever you go, they will find you a dive buddy. Do not fret.

But arguing or discussing which is better or best? Neither and Both!

You're going to want to do them numerous times... and some others, too!
 
Amen Doc.
CCV in May and Bonaire in July...hows that for as good as it gets??
Come on May!
 
If a low price is of interest then check out the Sept/Oct specials at Fantasy Island in Roatan. Great prices!
 

Back
Top Bottom