Thanks, everyone, for your advice. We're definitely going to Roatan, as we've already paid quite a bit to reserve the spot. I never really considered not going due to risk of illness. Rather, I wanted to know if I should take the all the precautions outlined on CDC website. The info the CDC gives out sometimes sounds worse than it really is, and I was hoping that was the case for Roatan. I think I'll skip the malaria prophylaxis and take my chances on that. Probably will get the Hep vaccine, bring some DEET and immodium, and hope for the best. I can hardly wait to go - too bad it's 7 months away.