Syman must not have been to San Andres to think FIBR sucks!
I have a 'rule' in the 50 countries I have been to in the world, not to go back because there are so many other places to see. I am breaking that rule to return to FIBR this christmas again. it is the best, most convenient diving I have ever done. No serious diver uses rental gear, so why make it an issue? My room was 3 doors from the dive shop; walk out the door, grab gear from locker and plop it on the boat. 20 min from bed to 40'.
Granted, the food was not 'gourmet', but no one starved and there was enough selection that vegetarians and shellfish allergies could have a choice every meal.
Personally, I would LOVE to go to CoCo View instead, but my buddy is not a 3-dive a day diver, so, topside IS a consideration.
Other points about West End convenience are true, its not close enough for nightly visits, but you HAVE to go once; it is a fantastic place, theres a bar called the Blue something-or-other with a dirt floor that just rocks!
It will be a great place to see lots of different things from macros (flamingo tongue, seahorses,juvenile spotted drum, Queen Blenny, all firsts for me) to turtles, eagle rays, spotted morays on night dives (they use your light to hunt, an amazing sight) are breathtaking.
it is mostly reef and wall diving; thats OK with me, all I see all summer here are wrecks, wrecks, wrecks, and zebra mussels!
I did get cold in a 5mm, but I am a cold diver. This year I will be in 8mm, and know I will be fine.
I hope you enjoy it!