I've been to LCBR twice (2010 and 2011) and Pirate's point most recently. I am hard pressed to say which one I like better, as they are both very good, but very different.
I'd probably give a slight nod to Pirate's point though I would be happy to return to either of them. Pirate's point only does two dives a day unless you elect to do a night dive or something, 9:30 ish and 12:00 ish, then a late lunch around 2:00. I like sleeping later when I am on vacation, and wanted some down time to read and relax which was missing a bit when I went to LCBR on a package. Pirates point allows you to manager you own dive profile, there is no attempt at making those dives a specific length. Mine were about 90 minutes, I came up because I was cold. It didn't disrupt anyone else, they would put me in the water first, and I'd rebuddy and play underneath the boat at the end. It was completely my call whether I wanted to follow a DM or not, some did, some didn't, and all of the groups were small. But there was always one DM in the water the entire time and the DMs were very experienced. I wanted to improve my fish id skills, so the DM would show me a couple of things in the book and give me a few things to look for. They were also very good at noting which divers needed a close eye and which did not. At LCBR, this was not always consistent from DM to DM though to this I say that divers are responsible for themselves and seeking the help and support that they need. And there were a couple of issues with lack of professionalism by a couple of dive staff members at LCBR although in general the dive staff was great. Probably just the day, the individuals, and the particular circumstances.
And as Craig said (hi Craig), to each their own. I did not like the food at LCBR and actually lost 4 pounds (a big PLUS in my book) as I'd only eat enough to get by. The food at Pirate's point is crazy good, and despite 3 hours of diving a day and a few really long bike rides, I gained 4 pounds. The owner did some time with Julia Child/James Beard, the head chef did his time in Napa Valley, and it shows.
I think my decision about which one to go back to would be very dependent on what kind of vacation I am looking for. And who I was traveling with.
Rooms at LCBR were much better, but I am a tub person!