Regulator setup?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

msilve

Guest
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Location
North New Jersey
# of dives
0 - 24
Trying to decide on a reg/octo/computer setup...

I kind of like the idea of DVT so the first stage doesn't get ruined and I definitely want a balanced reg.
I like the Sherwood Magnum and some of Oceanic's regs but I'm open to others.
My diving will mostly be northeast and possibly a Liveaboard to Belize soon! :D

Any help would be great! Thanks
 
Go with whatever works best for your style of diving & can be easily serviced in your area. I personally like the Scubapro MK25/ S600 (I have 6 of them) for its breatheability, but that is what works for me & is easily servicable in my area. Never ruined a regualtor yet, but I have dunked them a time or 2 without the dust cap on. I basically just had it serviced as soon as I got home,... no issues.
 
I don't have the DVT device on any of my first stages. I've been diving for about 12 years. Not one of my regs has been ruined. When I do post-dive, fresh water soaks with my regs, I make sure that the regs are in a pressurized state. This greatly decreases the chances of water infiltration of the first stage.
I believe that if a reg owner exercises a modicum of care, the Oceanic DVT or Aqualung ACD devices really aren't necessary. The usefulness of the feature has been somewhat inflated by the marketing arm of the companies.
I suppose that the DVT/ACD could be useful for rental regs that are exposed to rough handling by OW students.

I've heard good things about Sherwood and Oceanic regs.
If you'll be diving in cold water (temps. < 50°F), then it might be a good idea to get a first stage that's environmentally sealed. Features that help prevent second stage free-flows include metal construction and various "heat-sink" parts.
An experienced northeast diver would be able to tell you whether you need all or none of these features.
Another thing to consider is whether you can get a certain brand of reg serviced at your local dive shop of choice. In many cases, the breathing performance of a reg is directly correlated with the skill of the last reg tech who overhauled/serviced/tuned it.

A computer is a completely separate piece of scuba gear. It can come mounted in a console or on a wrist-mount.
I'd recommend getting something one that's nitrox-compatible.
If you are on a budget, I would recommend getting a non-air-integrated one.

Before buying anything, I'd recommend renting/demo-ing the gear to test whether it meets your needs.
 
Have to agree with tstorm. Scubapro MK25/S600 are great regulators; I personally own that setup. Sherwood makes good regulators particularly the Blizzard model for cold water diving since you live in the Northeast.
 
+1 MK25/S600, they dive great!!!
 
There are plenty of regs on the market that will do nicely.
Don't get hung up on the price or brands, most of mid range regs are just as good as the top of the line regs and there is little real difference in the quality or performance of any of the regs in the mid price range and above. Some of the major brands/models are way more expensive and all you are really getting for your extra money is name recognition and bragging rights. The major things you need to look for are features YOU want and service. Some regs like Scubapro and Aqualung will be easier to find service for than a lesser know brand but if you have a local shop that services a lesser known brand, they can be a much better value.
Instead of brands, think about how you will use the reg and what features are really useful. It would also be helpful if you learned a little about reg design. For example, for cold water diving, a sealed diaphragm first stage is a better choice than a piston, mechanically, they are better suited to handle cold water. For warm water the first stage design makes little difference in reg performance, contrary to what many would have you believe, the real determination of reg performance is in the second stage, the first stage has little effect on the overall performance of the reg. I would also suggest you avoid gimmick features. Not only do these cost extra, add things to break but add little real value to the reg......the DVT Is a prime example, put the dust cap on the reg like you are supposed to and there is no problem. Even if you do accidentally flood a reg with fresh water it's no big deal, that can be dealt with on site. Another gimmick is exotic materials, titanium for example. While it is more corrosion resistant I can see no reason to use it.....I have regs over 50 years old that are still in good shape, for the average diver I would think that is long enough.
 
I have always had Scubapro Regs.... But that is what my shop sells and services. MK25 first stages with various second stages, but my 600 is my favorite.:D I agree, find one that can be serviced by your Local shop.
 
If you plan on diving year-round in your area a good choice could be Scubapro MK17/G250V. I dive in winter with it in 37F waters and never had any troubles yet.
 

Back
Top Bottom