Although I made a different decision, I do respect and value the input of others that differ from my opinions. I thought long and hard about whether she was ready. I knew there would be some that cringed a bit when reading my post as children diving can be a touchy subject that sends everyone into their corner to defend their positions.
I only responded to the comment from DDM. I am not an expert in this subject and I can only make decisions for my kids and my dive school.