Mike
Contributor
As for Alison- I have wrestled with this a lot, and really don't want to taxi to the Caleta (I loved being picked up at the Southern resorts, and thought about staying at one again just for that- but better food was a draw to town) however, I'm an incredibly nervous diver and I know that diving with her I'm 'good'. I know that I can do a giant stride entry if I want to (and I generally do), I know I don't have to do any of the lifting of the gear, I know I can stay above 75 feet without getting a private DM (this one is HUGE, my doctors have advised I not dive below 80), I know she'll only go through wide, well lit swim throughs, and I know her rental gear is excellent. For me, taking out a lot of the unknowns is worth the inconvenience of a taxi.
When you find someone who has removed so many of your dive issues you've found a good fit. I'd be the same way, I'd at least get another trip under my belt and see if my diving improves/changes and if some of those issues were no longer factors after the next trip then it might make more sense to look around, but it's certainly understandable why you'd not make a change with a dive operator that has made you so comfortable and removed so many things that you'd now have to worry about again.