Kathy, as usual you are a wealth of Cayman info. I had to go back and check, they have made a few changes, looks like a 3 hour layover if we arrive on time.
My must have list...
Contacts, primary computer, reg set, wetsuit, mask and my Freedom backplate. Clothing optional.
Yeah, yeah I know. Rental won’t kill me but its been, ahem, a number of years since I have been in rentals. My ow class in fact.
So, I am looking at a medium size duffle (about a pound) or an ultralite roller bag (about 3 pounds). I already own both. Aside from weight, either more likely to be accepted on the plane?
I really don't know how the baggage handlers make decisions about what goes and what stays behind. I am sure that certain items have higher priority. There is a supply barge that comes to the island once per week (weather permitting) that carries a lot of perishables and other goods - but some stuff must come by plane.
Our last trip, the bag that was delayed looked just like our other bag that wasn't delayed and they weighed about the same, so it may just be luck!
When you are getting ready to leave the resort, you may be able to pack a bag and send it over to GCM a day in advance and that increases your chances of having all your bags arrive with you when you get home; but if they don't have room the bag will be waiting for you at LCM when you arrive the next day to fly out.
Years ago TACA airlines serviced areas of Central America including Honduras, and you could count on delayed and lost bags. People used to call it "Take A Chance Airline" or "Take Another Carrier Always"! I remember one time we were asked to select one bag (for both of us) that was guaranteed to be put on the plane with us. We carefully picked one bag and it was labeled with a colorful tag - and of course it was the only bag that didn't make it!
In the old days, ALM was the main air carrier to Bonaire, and everyone used to call it "Ah! The Luggage, Man!" airline.
Cayman Airways is much more reliable than any of those old-time carriers IMO. Most of the time your luggage arrives with you, or maybe one bag will arrive the next day; at least that has been our experience. But the luggage delays on LC may get worse during the winter - because it is the busiest season and the days are shorter - and the planes can only fly in and out of LC during daylight hours because the airport is unlighted.