Outward Bound School

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

2airishuman

Contributor
Messages
2,688
Reaction score
2,018
Location
Greater Minnesota
# of dives
200 - 499
Some of you may be familiar with the Outward Bound School, an educational organization whose original purpose was to teach a survival mindset to new sailors so that their chances of prevailing in a life-threatening emergency would be comparable to that of more experienced hands.

The organization and its programs have evolved over time, but they still teach the same core values and skills. I took the course many years ago at the Colorado school. While there are many facets to the course, the relevant ones here are:

1. They teach the skill of refusing to give up in the face of adversity, even when the odds seem overwhelming.
2. They teach that many of the limits we perceive in what we can do physically are in fact limits that are mentally enforced. Most people can reach farther, pull harder, run longer, etc., than they think they can.
3. They encourage a certain tenacity and stoicism in dealing with minor irritants and discomfort.
4. They teach a sober respect for safety given the inherent hazard in many of their activities.

It is my Deep Thought (tm) of the evening that all this applies directly to safe diving. I wonder whether Outward Bound graduates, as a group, make safer divers.

The other uncommon mental skill that safe diving requires is the ability to consciously and deliberately divide one's attention multiple ways in an emergency. Aviation -- flight training -- is the only place I've seen this taught deliberately as a skill of its own.
 
I think Outward Bound is great, have seen them in sailing lifeboats off the Maine coast over many years.

But in diving, I wonder if relevant value no. 1 may put you into trouble in scuba diving. If the conditions are adverse and the odds (against finishing the dive alive?) seem overwhelming, I'm thumbing the dive.
 
My personal opinion only. I think the best thing for you to do if you're in trouble on a boat is to stay on the boat and get out of trouble. The absolute worst thing to do is leave the boat. If the boat burns, stay on the boat (unless it's wood or fiberglass of course). If the boat is sinking, stay on the boat, do something about it, until the boat sinks out from under you. If you're in the water, climb on a boat. In this case, boat good, water bad.

If you're diving, and the world goes sideways on you, get on a boat. Never give up getting to the surface, regardless of decompression status, regardless of any other circumstances, get out of the water. In the case of a sideways dive, boat good, water bad.
 
I'm going to try to channel Tom Mount here who wrote in one of his books about this sort of thing, so he gets credit for the underlying idea. I don't have the book handy or I'd try for a direct quote.

Anyway, the idea isn't about refusing to thumb the dive. It's about refusing to give in to panic and despair even if the situation appears to be hopeless. On a boat, bail water even if you don't think you can keep up with the seas coming in. Diving, entrapped, keep trying to get loose. Diving, not enough air to make it to the surface, try to make it anyway.

Mount made a counterexample of cave divers on dives gone pear-shaped preparing touching and romantic notes to their survivors in their last moments, rather than doing something to try to save themselves.
 
If the boat is sinking, stay on the boat, do something about it, until the boat sinks out from under you.
I'm curious, what size of a boat when sinking (and speed) would a boat pull you under with the drag? As I have absolutely no idea. Or is that a myth?
 
Mythbusters says it's a myth. I was there for the sinking of the Texas Clipper, and I swear we were falling into the hole. Bubbles don't provide nearly the buoyancy as water does. Funny, then we'd be derigibles. What I'd worry about would be getting trapped underdeck with a lifejacket on. These things tend to tip over as they lose righting moment.
 
Damn y
Mythbusters says it's a myth. I was there for the sinking of the Texas Clipper, and I swear we were falling into the hole. Bubbles don't provide nearly the buoyancy as water does. Funny, then we'd be derigibles. What I'd worry about would be getting trapped underdeck with a lifejacket on. These things tend to tip over as they lose righting moment.
Damn you Hollywood producers of Castaway!!!!!
 
My personal opinion only. I think the best thing for you to do if you're in trouble on a boat is to stay on the boat and get out of trouble. The absolute worst thing to do is leave the boat. If the boat burns, stay on the boat (unless it's wood or fiberglass of course). If the boat is sinking, stay on the boat, do something about it, until the boat sinks out from under you. If you're in the water, climb on a boat. In this case, boat good, water bad.

USN 101, Don't give up the ship.

Or as an old Bos'ns Mate once told me out at sea, "the closest land is straight down".


Bob
 

Back
Top Bottom