The fact that a "cave diver" ran into him in Blue Springs is not far fetched at all. And wouldnt make me question that diver's ability either. For those of you not familiar with Blue Spring, the cavern itself is only about 6-10' wide X 25' wide or so. It can get VERY cramped in there when you have a class or two and then a few other divers. Gets a little tight to get by other sometimes. Myself and some friends dive there often and have gotten quite used to wiggling our way past OW classes. BTW, most of the instructors here take lots of pictures of their students on check dives AND training dives. Doesnt mean they are "preoccupied" or anything like that. The pics are an afterthought to them. The reason I am sure he was told to bring up the rear in this case is that you can't enter Blue Spring 3 or 4 at a time. 1 or 2 going in is about it. If the instructor goes in first(which is probably what happened) to watch the students descend, he may have asked HARLEY to come in last because of his demonstrated abilities at that point. If he was stronger at the skills and had more confidence that the others, he may well have asked him this to "keep an eye on others" on their way in. That is what I assume anyway. Seen it at this particular spring ALOT. That is pretty much standard if the instructor is by himself, i.e. has no other help with him to keep an eye on them.