One reason why I'm buying my own gear!

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Mortlock

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Messages
149
Reaction score
0
Location
Shizuoka, Japan
My wife and I are still novices (AOW with 40 dives) and we've always used good rental equipment in the past. On recent trip to the Philippines we convinced two of our friends to come along and get their OW cert. The wife and I did a heap of fun dives while they completed their course. So now they are certified although only with the four OW dives that come with the course. The place we were staying at was booked out and our reservation ran out so we headed to another area to do some diving together.

This dive centre was pretty shoddy. I'm no equipment specialist but alarm bells were ringing at how dodgy this place looked. Equipment obviously hadn't been cleaned after dives and there was sand and **** all through where all the equipment was kept. The instructor handed me a BCD to use and I refused as the inflator was too sticky and just generally screwed. He told we there wasn't anything else and I said fine, we'll cancel the dive then. Magically he produces a BCD that was a bit better. What I didn't know was that when I was checking everything he then handed the BCD I rejected to one of my newly certified friends.

So we're all on the boat and I'm looking at my cracked SPG and the dodgy clasp on my BCD's tank strap. Everyone else also has various minor problems with their equipment. We're diving on a wreck that's in 35m of fairly clear water (10m vis). My recently certified mates are concerned about going so deep but the instructor says that there's no current and they'll be with an instructor so it's cool. As I was worried about our ****ty equipment I told everyone (when the instructor wasn't in ear shot) to stick especially close together and be ready to support everyone else becuase the gear's so crappy. I didn't know that this bit of advice would save my friends life!

We decend down the line. I'm with my wife as one pair of buddies and our two mates are buddied up but I was keeping a close eye on them. When we get to the wreck my friend (with the dodgy BCD) suddenly goes flying uncontrolably to the surface! I happened to be looking at him at the time as he seemed to be having some kind of trouble and luckily I was able to power up to him and yank on the emergency dump valve on his BCD. His BCD was continusouly filling. With my hand on the dump valve I tried to disconnect his LPI but it was stuck solid! We get the attention of the instructor eventually and he takes over signaling to me that all is OK. I go back to my wife and we cruise around the wreck and it was great! I bumped my tank while going through a narrow passage in the wreck but it was cool going into this ship. About five mintues later I look over and my mate is on the instructors octopus being led around. By this time we had one minute left of no-deco time and needed to ascend. By the time we started to head up I could hear the instructors computer beeping away like crazy.

We go up to 10m and the instructor signals that we need to stay here for 10 minutes. The problem, he's got only 30 bar left after having my mate on his octo, my mates got 10 bar left, I've got 50 due I guess to my SPG which was pissing out bubbles the whole dive. The instructor puts my mate on my octo as he needs all his air now. At this moment, the dodgy clasp on my tank strap breaks and my nearly empty tank starts floating up. Now my mate and I have a tank hanging above our heads trying to pull the regs out of our mouths. My wife goes and tries to re-attach my tank but it's no use. By this time I've got less than 20 bar left and the isntructor signals that we now need to make a 5m 3min safety stop. I pass my mate to my wife's octo. She's pretty good with air consumption so she had enough left to spare. Our other friend isn't good with air and didn't have enough to spare. In the end we all get to the surface with basically empty tanks.

An absolute gong show that I think we were all lucky to walk away from!! A big factor in this I think was that we all stayed calm (kudos to our recently certified friends for this!) and knew each other so well.

What I've learnt:

I've now promissed myself that no matter how much I'm looking forward to a dive to always abort it if I'm not happy with the equipment that I or the other people in the group are using. This incident has also convinced me to get my own gear so I can keep it well maintained and hopefully never have to deal with this situation again!
 
Good to hear everyone is OK.

On the other hand, you noticed the equipment was in disrepair to start with and had yours changed. When you or your friends noticed that their equipment was also bad, your friends or you should have insisted it be changed or cancelled the dive as you were going to do for yourself, it doesn't matter if you were on the boat and at the dive site already. When you noticed you still had more bad equipment yourself, again cancel the dive. It doesn't matter if the DM is within earshot or not, in fact he should have been told. Don't be afraid to offend anyone if your life depends on it.

You stated that you are also novice divers so I have to ask, what were you doing entering a tight passage way on a wreck when you already knew you had unreliable equipment and you probably do not have the training or the equipment with you for wreck penetration. It might be cool going into the ship but if you can't get out how cool would that be.

You said that your advice saved your friends life but by not cancelling the dive it could have cost someone their life. It's good that you have learned something from this dive and it's good that you have shared this with everyone on the board. Practice makes perfect they say so keep at it and don't try to over extend your ability without the proper training.
 
getwet2:
On the other hand, you noticed the equipment was in disrepair to start with and had yours changed. When you or your friends noticed that their equipment was also bad, your friends or you should have insisted it be changed or cancelled the dive as you were going to do for yourself, it doesn't matter if you were on the boat and at the dive site already. When you noticed you still had more bad equipment yourself, again cancel the dive. It doesn't matter if the DM is within earshot or not, in fact he should have been told. Don't be afraid to offend anyone if your life depends on it.

Very true and that's definately something I'll be aware of in the future. Also good point regarding not worrying about offending anyone. Another thing we've all learnt from this dive!
 
Mortlock:
Very true and that's definitely something I'll be aware of in the future. Also good point regarding not worrying about offending anyone. Another thing we've all learnt from this dive!
This sounds like a really hard and dangerous way to learn - not how it's supposed to be! The dive was too deep - there were overheads involved....... and then the gear. It makes me shiver thinking about it. I'm really glad that you all came out OK - and without trying to get at you - I really hope you know (not guess) how lucky you all were.
 
Could have gone the other way qiuk.
Most of all I'm glad you learned a important lesson and shared it with us so others can learn from what happened to you.
Thanks
Fred
 
What was that instructor doing leading your friend around on his octo instead of aborting the dive, and obviously running into deco when he was low on air himself??
 
stefo2:
What was that instructor doing leading your friend around on his octo instead of aborting the dive, and obviously running into deco when he was low on air himself??
Five years ago, we got cavern certified in Akumal, Mexico. One basic rule that is firmly stated for cavern and cave diving is this...."If even one member of a dive team, for any reason, is uneasy...they can "call the dive" and no one questions why. I think the same should be for ocean diving. It's simply not worth the risk. No matter how "neat" the wreck was, I'm just glad you all made it through without anything bad happening. There will always be more opportunities to dive if we follow the rules. There will not be more opportunities if we don't. Glad things worked out. That operation shouldn't even be open!
 
Glad it worked out for the better for all of you, and a big pat on the back for keeping all your heads clear.

I won't go into what could have been done better, and what should have been done before you got into the water. I'm sure you have learned many valuable lessons from this. Thanks for sharing this lesson with the world; I hope that other new divers will learn the easy way, by reading your account of what happened.

Let us know how your “quest” for dive gear goes, and don’t be afraid to ask questions on gear you are considering. Also don’t be afraid to “not” take some advice, from some who feel that anything not “technical” is not worth buying and using. Questions on dive gear tend to be the second most debated subject, and one in which there are many "opinions".
 
lpedersen:
One basic rule that is firmly stated for cavern and cave diving is this...."If even one member of a dive team, for any reason, is uneasy...they can "call the dive" and no one questions why. I think the same should be for ocean diving.
Thought it was? It was certainly firmly stated in my OW class.
 
Learned my lesson on this first trip I ever went on. My instructor sold me a used BC(his idea). On last dive of trip when I surfaced heard hissing sound and Bc would not stay inflated. Got back on boat no problem. When I got home, I took it in. Old BC with some sort of weird valve. Not repairable. From then on, no more used equipment(other than lights, gloves). Definitely no used life support equipment. I take my own stuff everywhere.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom