Hey Mike,
Yeah, I was on Lanai for the weekend, then did Makena & Marty's Reef yesterday.
I agree with you on the "Boat" Adventure Dive... to me it has no more content than just going on a boat dive and getting the briefing has.
I suppose you could do the Carthaginian if you wanted a decent wreck, but then you'd have "deep" and "scooter" in that same dive, too.
You'd be surprised the skills involved in scootering... there's all the maintenance stuff to start with, then you go through all the in-water skills, too. Honestly, I'd put it at least as "meaty" as Night or PPB.
Have you been on a scooter?
Around here, I think you'll be hard pressed to find a shop that wouldn't first suggest a boat dive for the "Deep" adventure dive -- if you don't go off a boat, you'll either have a LONG surface swim, or do it by scooter. So, you'll have that one and then one other dive to pick from the boat, as they'll usually do a 2-tank boat trip.
I'm 8 days until my final dive, Mike -- next Thursday's the day! AND they're auctioning tickets to individuals that want to come along... well, not quite, but there's was a bit of a rush to get their names on that list.
With how much interest there is, and how much ribbing I've been getting over it already, I'm just going to go into it completely relaxed. I've seen what stress does to others doing their final dives (I've already been on one, and will be going on someone else's tomorrow), and it is completely counter-productive. The perceptual narrowing is actually quite incredible!
Anyways, I digress.
I'm probably going to be at Ulua tomorrow to tag along on the start of a referral, and I'll be in the water again on Saturday for the Scubaboard Maui Monthly -- are you working then, Mike? If not, do you want to join us for 9am?
To come back on topic -- I really like the list Mike picked, too -- I'm not sure what Naturalist entails... I've done Fish ID, and it was pretty intense, at least the way Teri from Maui Dreams does it. PPB is *superb*. Night diving here is *incredible*.
I think for me, it's a tossup. My AOW was Deep, Nav, PPB, Scooter and UW Photog. I did my EAN specialty at the same time. I've added National Geographic, Scooter, PPB, and AWARE Fish ID specialties, as well.