Okay, but what if I want to swim out three or four hundred metres? Maybe I'm being too ambitious.
Yes, likely so.
You've gotten the right advise so far. You might "not be learning" by reeling out a line (of any kind), but if it truly that bad, what could it hurt?
That thing about not being able to find the next pier 10 meters out? Hand your buddy a 10 meter line,
spread out and swim towards the target.... if you don't find it, take up knitting instead.
The need for covering large distances while diving has always eluded me. There is so much to see within confined areas, only if you slow down and take your time.
A different environment, sure, but under the town pier at St Croix, I watched divers swim waaaay out as far as they could and then come back... several dives. We never left (except once) the first 150' of the pier... all the cool stuf, everything we wanted to see... it was right there.
Flagging tape is useful. Easier to see than any knife mark. You can tie it to small sticks, rocks, or the pier itself. Put the knot towards a certain direction. Leave a trail of breadcrumbs, but clean up your mess.
If you'd have gotten one compass heading during one of your day dives (pylon to pylon) you would be a hero on your night dive!!!
And while you're at it, shoot the pier from walking on the top, in the light. Know what direction it's "supposed" to be pointing.