My shop sells ScubaPro, Henderson, Bare, Waterproof, Hollis, and maybe another brand or two that I can't think of right now.
The ScubaPro EverFlex or the Henderson Thermaxx would probably be my top choices. I am personally partial to the EverFlex because it fits me really well. We have the Reactive and our guys that have them really like them. But, I have heard too many stories of issues with the main zipper on the Reactive, including from my shop owners that have them. For that reason, the Bare would not be in my list of top choices. The other options are, I think, just as good for comfort/warmth, but are seemingly just a bit more robust.