I am not sure that I agree with all that is said in the video. At the end of my OW, my buoyancy control was poor. A couple of additional dives with my buddy did not fix that.
Not everyone wants to ask a fellow diver to be taught. Going to an agency is faster, and convenient.
Fair assessment - my buoyancy was also rough immediately after my OW course. I wonder if how useful a buoyancy course is is largely determined by how good your OW course was to begin with. My OW course consisted of maybe four pool sessions, then the checkout dives in the ocean. During these we'd descend, and smash into the bottom at 30 ft. Not sure anyone even bothered letting me know
that's now how you do that. Where I train now, they say they don't even let anyone into open water with fewer than NINE pool sessions - yet both schools are SSI-affiliated. I did end up taking the buoyancy course and it wasn't exactly exhaustive - one pool session, basically. I will say my buoyancy now is much better, but I think that's largely from just getting more time in the water. I'm guessing the real value, from any course, is what your instructor puts into it.
But it does open up a larger conversation about how OW courses should be taught - should students even be passed without having a fundamental grasp of buoyancy? You'd think not. Yes it takes time and practice to get it down just right, but you'd think they could equip you with all the necessary fundamentals during OW training.
So I would not call Buoyancy a BS course. IMHO, it is even the basis of all the other skills. I care about the skills. I don't care if no one will ever ask me a buoyancy certification card. Same think for navigation.
Couldn't agree more about it buoyancy being a core skill - along with breathing, trim, and propulsion. I'm a perfectionist in these areas (as in I
strive for perfection, not that I've attained it) so I understand the desire to learn the skill regardless of how often you'll be flashing your buoyancy cert. I think James' point on the video is that that offering and charging students for buoyancy lessons is inherently sketchy in his opinion, since he thinks an instructor should teach buoyancy as part of the OW course, not as an optional add-on.