New diver - seeking cold water dives opinions

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Next week I am taking an intro to scuba class to see if I will like it as much as I think I will, before I drop the big money on the certification class. If I do end up getting my certification, is there any reason NOT to do a dry suit class right away, and then make the dry suit my first purchase once I have the funding? I’m not a fan of being cold, and that’s what all my dives would most likely be. I live in MN with no money to travel to warmer waters.
 
Drysuits do add a little bit of a task load, but aren't that bad. Some agencies (SDI comes to mind, not sure about others) allow you to actually do your open water cert dives in a drysuit (provided that your agency/shop lets you do your drysuit training in the pool beforehand)..

I suppose ultimately it comes down to how comfortable you are with your skills on your first few dives.. If you're comfortable with being in the water, a drysuit right away isn't going to over complicate things.. If you're not comfortable in the water at the start, a drysuit might be a bit much.
 
Makes sense I guess...
 
Drysuits do add a little bit of a task load, but aren't that bad. Some agencies (SDI comes to mind, not sure about others) allow you to actually do your open water cert dives in a drysuit (provided that your agency/shop lets you do your drysuit training in the pool beforehand)..

PADI does as well.

If you are going to be diving dry as an important part of future diving, you might as well get started on it right away.
 
To the OP: IMO, the most important aspect of your initial cold water dive is your attitude going into the experience, and it sounds like yours is just fine. Remember that when your LDS was a bit discouraging, there was a reason. They believe there is a possibility you will not enjoy the experience. If you really want to do it (and it sounds like you do), and you expect there will be some uncomfortable coldness involved that you will have to get past, you should be OK. This is especially true if the people you are diving with are as helpful as you are expecting them to be.

Cold water diving is a lot like drinking scotch. For many people, it is an acquired taste, but once that taste is acquired, it is hard to beat.
 
Dude, you need to update your profile or really thank your instructor! This is solid advice from someone with less than 50 dives.

Jim, I really appreciate your praise. My profile is accurate. I just did my 30th dive a month ago. It was my first time in fresh water (Paradise Springs, FL). I was heavily over-weighted and too hot in my 7mm suit. I forgot I could just let in the water to cool off. I still have so much to learn. :)

I was trained for OW in a typical two-day resort course. Looking back, it was a competent program, but nothing special and way too short. After no diving for several years, I found a "retired" DM who wanted a buddy. He'd been off a few years, too. We started with a checkout dive where the locals do their OW checkouts (Breakwater in Monterey Bay). There I learned about so many things I didn't quite remember from my cert class. And, I lost control of my buoyancy and had a runaway ascent just like I mentioned. I really wanted to understand what went wrong and why, so I studied my buoyancy much more carefully on later dives.

A few months (and dives) later we took another noob to check him out in the same way. He had exactly the same problem with buoyancy and runaway ascent. Then, a month later I did a San Diego dive with an insta-buddy. She had more dives than I, but all guided in Hawaii. She had exactly the same problem with buoyancy and runaway ascent. I think I spotted common problem. :)

My DM dive buddy has been a great mentor. He's not really instructing me, but he provides an opportunity for me to practice my skills and talk about how to improve. (Especially navigation; he gets lost so easily.) ;) So, even though I have logged only 30 dives, I'm pretty comfortable in my native waters, and I've worked with a few divers new to cold water. I watch what I do and notice enough mistakes to know that I need way more skill and training.

When I vacation-dive in San Diego, I'm on my own. I love diving with people more experienced than me, because I learn so much. But I feel sorry for them because my air consumption cuts their dives short. Other times I've led dives on sites I've never seen before because I'm the one with the most relevant experience (kelp). I talk with the boat DM to get as much info about the site as I can. I really try to plan the dive well and be as safe as possible. Thankfully I've never had to deal with a rescue situation.

I love this sport, and I want to be as safe a diver as possible. I'm always looking for opportunities to improve my skills. Hopefully later this month I'll finally finish that AOW course I keep rescheduling. Eventually I'll follow it with other courses, and maybe even go pro (for semi-retirement). But, most of all, I need to dive to hone my skills.

So, thanks again for your kind words.
 
Next week I am taking an intro to scuba class to see if I will like it as much as I think I will, before I drop the big money on the certification class. If I do end up getting my certification, is there any reason NOT to do a dry suit class right away, and then make the dry suit my first purchase once I have the funding? IÃÎ not a fan of being cold, and thatÃÔ what all my dives would most likely be. I live in MN with no money to travel to warmer waters.

If your dive shop rents drysuits, they may be willing to throw in the drysuit cert along with your OW cert....and if you can do your certification in a drysuit, you will be happy! Talk with your dive shop, see what they recommend.

If, however, the dive shop does not rent drysuits, I'd definitely look into the drysuit as your first major purchase post-certification. There are many threads on what order to buy gear....appropriate exposure protection is always one of the first ones.
 
Cold water diving is a lot like drinking scotch. For many people, it is an acquired taste, but once that taste is acquired, it is hard to beat.


Great statement!

I'm from Sweden, here it's 'cold water diving' all the time.
I've done tropical diving as well, but I can easily say that all my dives here at home has been far better than those i've done tropical.
 
Rent a two piece 7mm. You'll have 14mm of wetsuit around your trunk. I dive a wetsuit, but I'm a wimp and don't hit the water until around the 4th of July based on previous experiences. YMMV
 
My 2 friends that invited me along are very experienced - 1000's of dives. I have already made it clear to them that I do not want them trying to goad me into doing anything that I wasn't comfortable with :no: and they fully respect and understand that. I know that many many diving incidents are caused by divers diving outside their comfort zone. I made it clear to my buddies that I don't want to go deep or anything remotely technical I just want to get wet and experience some local diving.

Your attitude is really good. The last thing you want to do is let ego push you past doing what you feel 100% comfortable with. It's nice when people can speak up like that - it really stops a lot of potential situations from happening.

I dove a 5mm in 50-52 degree water a few months ago (with hood/gloves/etc) and it was tolerable, barely. The cooler full of hot water to pour down it before each dive as well as after to warm up between dives really does go a long way!

If you own your own gear and are going to use it, make sure it's OK to use in cold water - depending on how cold of course - check with the shop you got it from.

Once you start the dive, if you get too cold you can end the dive at any time. Your dive buddies will agree that anyone can end a dive for any reason at any time.
 

Back
Top Bottom