My wife Erin and I were on the same dive and agree with everything you've said however, our guide from Lahaina Divers could have been a little more useful, maybe next time he'll bring all of his gear with him. We were pleasantly surprised by the boat and their efficiency (as well as the immaculate head), our surprise guest Les was pleasure. As far as the cookies go, they really weren't all that great (haha). I'm not sure if we'll use Lahaina Diver's again, with my experience in the military I don't know if I want to use my leave to have orders given to me more sternly than at work! All in all a good experience, great dive, excellent shop with extremely friendly personnel.