Thanks for info Deba and Kathy!
So is the diving "better" on Roatan or Utilia? I don't care about night life, perfectly happy to cook for myself and read a book on the beach.
Looks like Continental has a direct flight from Newark on Saturdays, which is nice 'cause all the other ones I saw were in the 25 hour range with layovers at LAX or Houston...I don't have enough vacation time to waste it in airports more than I have to.
I don't know. I did one dive in Roatan and 4 weeks in Utilia. Didn't see much of a difference, but sorry I don't have enough experience to compare.
The dives on the North side of Utilia are quite nice. But you'd probably have to find a way on to one of the "resort boats" at the larger shops or dive with Captain Morgans to dive that side daily as most shops don't want to waste the gas.
Top side in Utilia was more relaxed. I was there Jan 09 so don't know what's changed.