Old designs can be improved. Look at all the interest in the Atomic TFX.Using a piston device to perform the same function as a diaphragm is nothing new. White Stag did a very similar design in the 60’s.
The US Divers (now Aqua Lung) UDS-1 triple tank system has a what they called a Conshelf 1st stage regulator built right into the triple tank manifold. But instead of a diaphragm it actually had a sliding piston to perform the diaphragm function. It appears that it was done to facilitate assembly in to the valve. ...
I like diaphragms… they work so well that we use them in all current production second stages (we did use some bellows is some second stages in the 50’s). Try using a piston on a second stage and let me know how that works for you. The reason it doesn’t work may not be intuitively obvious, but that is a different discussion.
I have no idea if this design works better than the conventional way of environmentally sealing a diaphragm first stage by using a second diaphragm. Especially at recreational depths. But I do think it's worth a look. Mares actually bought an ANSTI testing machine to aid in their reg development. As a result of this, any of their first stages that can be fitted with this, even the budget 15X, are now certified to meet the Norsok U-101 standard at 200m. That means impressive stability at very high flow rates, even accounting for the lower density of the 97/3 Heliox mix that is specified by the standard.
Scuba diving Ansti machine | Mares
The ansti machine is used to measure our regulator performance, simulating the breathing conditions of a diver underwater, factoring in diving depth, breathing rate, inhale and exhale forces and characteristics such as cracking effort.
www.mares.com
But what I really want to know is what @rsingler thinks of Mares' new generation of balanced adjustable second stages. The Dual Adj is the workhorse of their current lineup. They also have an all-metal version called the Atlas Adj. The downstream Atlas (without the "Adj") is presumably their replacement for the Abyss so a comparison would be useful.
To round it out, I'd like to hear his thoughts on their Twin Power System. It's sort of a dive/pre-dive switch which they have on both a downstream second (the Ultra) and a pair of balanced adjustable seconds (Ultra Adj and Epic Adj). To my mind it's an unnecessary gimmick and potential failure point.