Looe Key resort has paper thin walls. I'll never go back there, not if you paid me. Parmer's is best bet to stay in the immediate area (305-872-2157), lots of room options. There are a few restaurants around, one a few doors down from Parmers, one on Sugar Loaf and one at Saddle Bunch. Much better food than No Name Pub. Big Pine Key Fishing Lodge, immediately on left as you cross the bridge onto the island, has rooms and camping. On same road, Longbeach Drive, there are a couple of Bed & Breakfasts. But now being able to text "BTDT" (been there done that), I would advise that the drive up to Marathon is not bad at all, and there are lots of great places to eat there. Marathon is the commerical fishing hub for all the Keys, so seafood is the freshest. There are lot of places to stay in Marathon. After having stayed nearly everywhere there is to stay in the Looe Key area except Little Palm Island ($900/night, which would require Angolina Jolee to dump that faggy Brad and call me before I could justify that tab) the boys and I are not going to stay on Big Pine anymore for a Looe Key dive - Marathon does it for me. Not the drunks and aliens of Key West, cheaper, fresher seafood than Key West, more options, more laid back. The dive charter we have used most for the Looe Key reef is Strike Zone Charters (305-872-9863). They are the last dive shop on Big Pine, on the right as headed to Key West, just before you leave the island, and boat is right behind the shop, minutes from the reef. Its a new dive shop, but the family has owned and run a dive place there for years. Cheapest rate too. Good luck, have fun, stay safe. Will in Sarasota