Aloha Joe
Contributor
I personally would do the advanced boat (first choice) and long range (second choice). Advanced boats are smaller groups, and long range will hopefully make you not feel like you could have done the same dive from the shore. Every time I've been on Big Island, those trips are either sold out, or cancelled, or something. Some dive shops won't let you do advanced unless you've dived with them before, because they want to ensure everyone is comfortable. My advanced trip with Jack's was cancelled, so I did a local boat dive. As said above, most dive sites are literally feet away from the coastline, and there's plenty of shore diving to do there. So why not use the boat to do something you can't do w/o a boat? That's my thought.