We've stayed at LCBR, Southern Cross, and Pirates Point. All three are excellent. LCBR has a lot more capacity, but they manage it very well. A lot of the rooms don't have ocean views--lifestyle choice. Both SCC and Pirates have exceptional food, and Pirates wins this category; people come there from the other resorts for dinner. All three have loyal clientele, and all three have good dive operations. Pirates Point has a brand-new boat, but it's a short van ride from the resort to their boat, while SCC and LCBR have docks. Pirates Point has been redoing their cottages, and the renovated ones are excellent--the one we were in had a back door which opened only to a few trees and then the beach. Pirates Point has a bit of a hippie vibe (they have a range of rooms and cottages), and several of the guests when we were there were European. Bottom line for us, Little Cayman is fantastic, all three properties are terrific, and the resort and dive staffs are great.