I started out with a Dive Rite Classic Light 50W Halogen during my cavern course that is sold at the shop that sits on Devils System Property.
It was like the Sun. Unfortunately too big for diving it with a single tank. I tried everything while I was diving a backinflation softpack and finally left it on a weight belt. Expensive ditchable weight.
I up (down) graded to the Dive Rite 10 W wreck 1 as soon as it came out. That night I went to Cow Springs around 9 pm at night. It was 28 F outside and the spring was nice and clear. My buddy decided to wait outside of the water while I played with this light in the open water basin. I was in love.
Then my dives started to get longer than 2 hours. I burned that battery for 2:45 mins one time...then it died
but atleast I didn't.
I picked up a Pro 14 50 W from EE in hopes of getting the 18 HID.
At the time that all the stars lined up to get the HID head. I was getting ready to move to South Florida and start single tank diving.
I decided on the Pro 6 10W as a better alternative to use it for single and double tank diving.
Now I just wait and save my pennies for the Helios set up. 18W hid for 4 hours, EE quality and it is small.
Oh ..I buy everything in two's so my buddy is currently using a pro 6 10 HID and we'll up grade together.
good luck...your best bet is pick up a rental or ask a buddy to let you try theirs.