" The quote above suggests some pretty unorthodox thinking. Most of my gear is negatively buoyant... tanks, lead, regs etc. Why would you ever want to ditch this stuff (with the exception of lead!)??? "
Because I can or maybe just because I'm the type that has to know what happens when I do. Personally I don't like the feeling of being dragged down or shoved about when I'm underwater.
I need to know what happens when or if I ditch any part of my equipment. No, I don't see myself playing "el toro" with an enraged octopus and my shortie at 90', but it gives me a feeling of security to know exactly what I can remove and let go of while knowing truly what happens next.
Who knows, some day I might not be doing it just to prove I can. And I'll know what I need to keep and everything I can possibly cut loose. I don't like nasty surprises. Though, I couldn't agree with you more that I need more experience (I'm working on it
) I don't have the blithe confidence in scuba equipment that would allow me to strap on weighting and happily sink away without knowing exactly what role each and every piece of the puzzle plays.
No disrespect intended. I tend to express my opinions when I'd be better off just keeping my mouth shut
I don't just want to know what happens if I remove my bcd at 40', I do know. I know what happens if I drop my weight belt too. I'm on a tether line so there is no risk. My buddy knows what hes doing. I'm just curious and I don't like not knowing or trusting in something just because thats the obvious rule. If I wasn't just playing around I don't think I'd be any use to myself or anyone else if confronted with a situation where I read something that says do this; don't do that. Knowing how to counter doffing my weight belt - exiting my bc - or even surfacing with just a handful of soft weights is not only fun to work on it goes a long ways towards making me less reluctant to pile on the gear to begin with. And a million times more likely to actually try to help someone else if they get into trouble. I used to dive with one hand on the anchor and a 12" screwdriver for prying things lose in the other. I'm still trying to open my mind around the concept of scuba and yeah, I want to know where my boundaries and limits are and how close I can get in a safe practice drill with someone I trust. Finding out I've gone too far or not knowing what to expect in the one in a million chance I might ever need to do something different isn't my favorite option.