I have followed this discussion with great interest since I have an 11 year old daughter who will be taking PADI's junior scuba course in late July. Concerns about injuries to kids are real and with kids involvement in diving there will be both injuries and deaths. Should this reality prevent a childs participation? IMHO it should not. If we(as a dive community) decide that it should then maybe we should as a society not allow kids to participate in other activities that present dangers to them. Football comes to mind since I'm plagued by problems with injuries that occured when I was 14. Horseback riding competitions since I saw my daughter go off a horse and the recent death of a 12 year old girl when a horse fell on her after going over a jump. The list could go on. I don't know the details of the PADI limitations for under 15 years of age yet but will before she dives outside of a pool. I will reserve the right to modify PADI's limits to something more restrictive ie less depth and less time maybe only one dive per day or doubling surface interval if there is a repetive dive. I guess this is one area where I feel the responsibility is squarely on the parent. Thanks for a great discussion.