Personal calculation. In my opinion a couple of dives in a tropical location are almost always worth the hassle.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
I have dove with the dive ops provided by Carnival in Belize, Honduras (Roatan) and Cozumel.
I would have no issue diving with any of them again.
In the case of Belize, the ship anchors miles off shore due to the shallow waters. The dive op picks you up directly from the ship eliminating the need to take a tender to shore. 15 min boat ride to dive shop. 15 mins out to the reef for two tank dives. Hugh Parkey is name of operation.
In Roatan, they use Anthonys Key Resort. Shuttle picks you up and transport you from port to resort.
Cant remember name of op in Cozumel but tthey meet you at end of pier for short walk to boat.
None of them had more 6 divers on the boat.
I dont remember them being anything out of line price wise. 75 to 100 bucks were the standard for all of Carnival's dive excursions, all two tank boat dives.The only thing I wonder about is the cost of using a cruise line selected shop... are the rates for two dives the same as if you arranged it yourself? I don't mind if a two dive trip is $100 from the ship versus $75, but if its nearly double, I'd just as soon make a couple phone calls and get to the dive shop myself (principle kind of thing)...
Anyway, thoughts on that?
I dont know what you consider expensive, but picking me up from the ship to avoid having to tender, that is worth something to me. I have been on Hugh Parkey's boats twice, and I can't remember there being 12 people including the Captain and mate, 3 dive masters and customers.Kathy, I'm assured it's not an issue, it flies very low - and only for about 15 minutes. But I'm appreciative of the feedback and it sure does sound like a needless hassle and a risk, given the time available. I think I'm going to pass and either do something I can't do elsewhere or maybe try the cruise ship offer and compare it with the others that I've arranged myself, like the one in Cozumel and Grand Cayman. It does sound like the cruise ship one, although convenient is a.) more expensive and b.) more crowded.
...and you want to talk about a cattle experience, cruise ship cave tubing IS IT . We went cave tubing during our non-cruise-ship trip to Belize in December. We were in a small group, but saw from a distance the cruise hordes. Think of 60+ screaming cave tubers all bunched together........moooo. Hard to escape from the hordes of people on a cruise ship...