Integrated weights?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Because of this issue, I've taken 20 lbs out of my BC integrated weight pockets and put them on a rubber weight belt, leaving 18 lbs in the BC.

Works much better if I have to don & doff and it's MUCH easier to lift my rig on land when kitting up.
 
Well thanks everyone - particularly for a balanced solution. I'll stick some lead on my weight belt (ahem, I mean harness) and some in my BC. I work out the ratios at my next pool session.

In terms of weight pockets falling out - yes, clearly this is a risk. I do try to be anal about my self check but people make mistakes, myself especially.

Just as a minor point of reality to reflect the drill: last year, through my own stupidity, I got my lanyard all tangled up in my SMB line. My buddy was descending (in 1-2m viz) and my lanyard was being pulled upwards. He disappeared in a couple of strokes. It was a very shallow dive so I simply ascended, detangled, and went down again.

However, if I had been deep, and got tangled, my buddy long gone, and I needed to dof/don my BC to detangle this would have been VERY challenging, if I needed one hand to stop me rocketing to the surface.

I know I'm a novice, but try doing skills with one hand, whilst buoyant, underwater.

Now add some pressure and a few extra tasks.

Not so easy is it?

As mentioned, I'm going to move weight between my and my dragon so we're all happy.

Happy diving, thanks,
John
 
Been diving with integrated weights for some time now and never experienced the "slip out" problem. Make sure clips are properly inserted before you enter the water is the answer. Once you have checked, check it again. It takes no time and could prevent difficult situations under water. Bottom line is prevention is better than cure.
 
..and if someone does lose the weights i have a growing collection of weights and pouches ive picked up from various dive sites that have fallen out of WI jackets. Then again, with the cost of lead these days its coming in quite useful !
 
Just as a minor point of reality to reflect the drill: last year, through my own stupidity, I got my lanyard all tangled up in my SMB line. My buddy was descending (in 1-2m viz) and my lanyard was being pulled upwards. He disappeared in a couple of strokes. It was a very shallow dive so I simply ascended, detangled, and went down again.

I know I'm a novice, but try doing skills with one hand, whilst buoyant, underwater.

Are you talking about the lanyard on a light? If so get a Goodman type Handle. That will give you 2 free hands. Makes a huge difference.

As regards integrated weights I would never use them. IMHO the risk of them accidentally falling out at depth far outweighs any benefits they might have.
 
Are you talking about the lanyard on a light? If so get a Goodman type Handle. That will give you 2 free hands. Makes a huge difference.

As regards integrated weights I would never use them. IMHO the risk of them accidentally falling out at depth far outweighs any benefits they might have.
If the pouches, bc and attatchments is properly maintained and used thats not a problem. User errors occur with all gear, including weight belts..
 
I'm not going to trust my life to a bit of velcro when I'm at 200 feet. Just my opinion.

most BC's i've rented had a clip in addition to the velcro holding the weights in.
 
I've seen a lot of people with integrated weights doff and don at depth (after bugs mainly or to take a picture under a ledge, not entanglement issues). Never seen any issues... I personally don't find it a hassle as I just swim down if I start to float up, if you practice you'll be fine. Weight belts I find very uncomfortable as they poke into my hips (I think maybe this is more a female problem as I've only heard women complain about this) so prefer the integrated weights.

I think both weight belts and weight pockets are easily lost if people are not careful. I've seen more people lose their weight belts though and I find far more of them on the bottom fwiw... I nearly lost a weight belt a few weeks ago too, it kept slipping so I tried to spin it around and the buckle popped (so yes that was user error but weight pockets are more idiot proof in my opinion). I caught it though in time. Pockets I find very secure, though a buddy did lose one of those stupid Tusa pockets (the ones where you pull a tab and they come out). My pockets buckle in and I find them very secure, but nothing is immune to failure.
 
I personally don't find it a hassle as I just swim down if I start to float up, if you practice you'll be fine.

Try that with a drysuit and 12-14kg of positive buoyancy. If you can swim that down you're a hell of a lot fitter than i am!
 

Back
Top Bottom