
I, too, stayed at the Inn over Memorial Day in 2005 and it was truly wonderful. Andy, the owner and builder of the Inn, along with Vern and Melissa, the managers, make you feel as if you are part of a family instead of a customer.
They have two big dive boats that you can see on their website. When we were there we never had more than 8 divers to a boat and they could easily hold 12+. If they have a good number of people staying in the resort they will divide the divers between the boats based on the experience level of the divers. Of course, if you are advanced and your buddy is a beginner they will not spilt you up. Most dives were right at an hour long except of the deeper wreck dives.
The food is good quality and there is not a lack of it either. Breakfast is made to order while lunch and dinner is served off the menu with several choices for the main course. One night you have a bbq at the lagoon during sunset which is a lot of fun.
One of the things that I really liked about diving with the Inn was that they never made you feel as if you were on a schedule. You did not feel like you had to set an alarm clock (heaven forbid on vacation) to get all your dives in during the day. I have been spoiled by the shore diving freedom of Bonaire so no schedule means a lot to me while I am on vacation. The dive staff is very nice and will help you as much or as little as you want them too.
If you have any other questions feel free to send me a PM.